WRITE A REVIEW
58% would repurchase
Package Quality: 3.8
Filter by skin/hair/eye
Filter by age
Start your review
on 2/11/2015 12:23:00 AM
More reviews by Aimbl
Skin: Combination, Olive, Not Sure
Hair: Brunette, Other, Other
I have both the EdP (discontinued curved glass flacon with dots and gold top) and the vintage Extrait. EdP is lovely and if you find it on line for a good price, I recommend it (Reviews seem divided as to whether there is a pine sol note in EdP. I recently discovered that I am not a particular fan of pine in perfume and feel that SL Fille de Aiguilles smells like a holiday room scent). The Bellodgia EdP does come across as slightly lemony on my skin, a trait the extrait doesn't really have. Vintage Extrait (mine is significantly more red toned than the fragrance depicted above ) is almost dusky in scent - absolutely wonderful- an incense warm, glowing carnation, clove with sandalwood and a bit of vanilla. There is no sharpness or mustiness or harshness that some people feel is characteristic of vintage fragrance. No powderiness that is characteristic of certain Guerlains. I recommend dabbing fragrance, not spraying, as It reduces powderiness and sillage. IMO, the extrait is close in character to vintage discontinued Malmaison which is also warm and glowing carnation. No soapiness or excessive rose or geranium. Although the dry down is smoothed by vanilla and wood, it's neither gourmand nor masculine. It doesn't have much oriental darkness like discontinued Caron Extrait strength Parfum sacre or modern dark fragrances. Some reviews on other fragrance sites describe Bellodgia as evocative of carnations in the bright sun which I can see more with respect to EdP. The parfum is more lush and more velvety than that, but in my older vintage, the top notes have also faded.Incidentally, I agree with Jayne58 that vintage extrait and JAR. Diamond water are somewhat along the same scent continuum, and that this differs substantially from the discontinued Lorzeno Villarossi Garafano (on me, Garafano reads as soapy geranium carnation). Current IFRA severely restricts the amounts of Eugenol and carnation, so I personally would not purchase current reformulations. By the way, IMO, Piu Bellodgia, a variation of EdT in a very cute faux stingray covered travel flask is NOTHING like bellodgia proper, and I do not recommend it. The only stingray flask EdT I recommend is Nuit de Noel.
on 1/18/2014 6:06:00 AM
More reviews by violette
Skin: Very Oily, Medium, Warm
Hair: Black, Wavy, Medium
A lovely carnation confection with that signature Caron dark vanilla base. Bellodgia is delicious stuff & like Nuit de Noel, was love at first sniff for me. This is for the current EDT in the purple box, which, according to purists, is not worth the bother. But I beg to differ... although I have never experienced the original/vintage, I still think the reformulation is beautiful & CERTAINLY doesn't deserve the vilifications. I've smelled MUCH, MUCH worse reformulations of classics that should've just died a dignified death a long time ago & believe me, the Carons don't count among them. My only gripe, of course, is the poor longevity... thankfully, the EDT lasts exceptionally well (& smells absolutely scrumptious) on clothing. And for the record, I don't get the pine note mentioned by msm4slm & ellizam below.The notes from Fragrantica:Top: Carnation, RoseHeart: Jasmine, Lily-of-the-Valley, Violet Base: Musk, Clove, Vanilla, SandalwoodThe notes from Michael Edwards:Top: Carnation, Ylang-ylangHeart: Carnation, Lily-of-the-Valley, Jasmine, Rose Base: Sandalwood, Musk
1 of 1 people found this helpful.
on 4/30/2013 5:59:00 PM
More reviews by fergiefergie
Skin: Combination, Fair, Not Sure
Hair: Brown, Other, Other
Ordered a sample of this from Lucky Scent. Had such high hopes for it, as Iove the spicy scent of carnations. I have dry skin that is notorious for devouring fragrances. Unfortunately, it devoured this one almost instantly. Applied it 30 minutes ago. Have to press my nose against my wrist to barely smell a soapy nothing of a scent.
on 1/15/2013 2:43:00 PM
More reviews by debrsl
Skin: Dry, Other, Not Sure
I've been able to try two versions of Bellodgia; there was quite a difference between the two. The first was a vintage cologne. The topnotes were unpleasant, but then the carnation itself unfolded. I'm not sure exactly what was off, as the only topnote listed is carnation, and the carnation itself was beautiful. Also incredibly beautiful was the drydown; just stunning. Rich. The next sample was the modern EDT. It was pathetic. I had to use the whole 2 ml sample to obtain any scent. It went straight to carnation; however, it was not nearly as full-bodied as the carnation in the vintage cologne. And there is none of the gorgeous drydown in the modern version at all. In short, unless you want a weak, simplistic carnation fragrance, don't bother with the current EDT. If you can find a vintage that doesn't have a poor beginning--or if you can just wait through that--the vintage is a great carnation fragrance.
on 9/6/2012 4:14:00 PM
More reviews by remychic
Skin: Dry, Fair, Neutral
Hair: Red, Straight, Fine
I have the edp version of this and I find it to be quite lovely. It is a spicy carnation-based floral. I don't smell pine at all, which other reviewers mention on the edp so I would recommend trying it first. The sillage is excellent. After 12 hours I could still smell it on my arm. If you like carnations and spicy florals I would recommend that you try it first. I plan on keeping it in my perfume collection with a consistent rotation because I find it to be a perfect carnation fragrance.
on 6/6/2012 3:31:00 PM
More reviews by alba75
Skin: Combination, Fair-Medium, Not Sure
Hair: Black, Other, Other
Bellodgia is a lovely perfume with warm notes of carnation, clove and cinnamon. The perfume is not cloying, when worn during sweltering summer heat. It is spicy and light at the same time. Alas, it smelt like "Red Mosow" by Novaya Zarya on me.
on 2/14/2011 5:37:00 AM
More reviews by kerriki
Age: 56 & Over
Skin: Normal, Fair, Warm
Hair: Brunette, Wavy, Fine
The old Bellodgia was lovely...how misguided I was in the days (before I realised one had to collect everything beautiful, never even dreaming it would just disappear) when I thought I could go back and get it...Old Bellodgia is beautifull...the new one does not even approximate it...Somehow it is just a zingy dusty sort of thing...its not rock bottom, in fact quite unusual and definitely worth trying, but never buy the new vesion unsniffed...
3 of 3 people found this helpful.
on 4/20/2010 9:49:00 AM
More reviews by msm4slm
Skin: Oily, Fair, Not Sure
Please read Ellizam's review below. I recently purchased the edt version of Bellodgia. I had a sample of the pure parfum from the Perfumed Court and loved it. I personally love to spray perfume, so I thought I would try the edt instead (avoiding the edp per Ellizam's advice). I love Caron's Muguet du Bonheur and get excellent results with the edt. So why not? Unfortunately, it has been my experience that the edt also has a very strong pine note. Ellizam is right on the target when she describes it as such below. She describes it perfectly but I would add I do not recommend the edt, either. I also want to say that I get very little powdery quality which I had hoped for, even in the drydown. I guess I was hoping for a carnation version of Muguet du Bonheur, but in this case that awful pine note just really dominates! I do not want to do this perfume injustice, however, as the pure parfum was just lovely. Too bad we can't send a letter to Caron (What WERE you thinking; don't you smell this stuff before you release it with your good name on it??)! Perhaps they are just unfamiliar with Pinesol and the fact that American women don't want to smell like household cleaner?? I also caution I am unsure as to whether I received a vintage or new version of the pure parfum from Perfumed Court. I will be more cautious in the future as to which version I purchase--particularly with Carons.
2 of 2 people found this helpful.
on 11/22/2009 5:16:00 PM
More reviews by ellizam
Skin: Combination, Other, Not Sure
Bellodgia is a tricky little product. I long suspected that different formulas are used in the different concentrations and one MUA'er claims she got confirmation of this at Caron in Paris. Here's what I can attest to: the edt and the parfum are spicy/floral confections of carnation (cinnamon and clove-y kind), lily, and jasmine over the classic creamy/vanillic Caron base. The edp is different and to my nose, unpleasant, with a distinctly predominant pine note. You can find the pine note, or rather a hint of the pine note in the edt and parfum, but it is overwhelming in the edp and not in a good way.The lotion, especially the lait version, are exquisite, and the sillage of Bellodgia is a dream. As with all Carons, the packaging is glorious. I've not noticed a particular difference over age with this, and the parfums I've gotten in it were both quite nice. I'm not sure this is a fragrance where one needs the parfum -- the edt is lasting and has good sillage and basenote retention. One does not, ever, for any reason (unless one is a pine note afficianado, poor creature) need the edp. Frankly, I'm a little pissed off at the tweak. Why on earth would they foreground the pine note? -- it's awful.
6 of 8 people found this helpful.
on 10/19/2009 10:33:00 PM
More reviews by reikigoddess
Skin: Sensitive, Fair, Neutral
Hair: Blond, Wavy, Fine
Can anyone comment on the parfum/extrait vs. the EDT & EDP. I've tried both the EDT & EDP and while it's a beautiful scent it's WAY too powdery for me. I'm finding that Carons, like Guerlains, are really worth the investment for the pure perfume. If I smelled Farnesiana in EDT or EDP I would never have wanted to even try the extrait & it's absolutely gorgeous, imo.
Are you sure this product is discontinued?
daasfdsad, asdadasd, addasdasdas, asdasdasdasfsdfgdfs, fgdssdgfdgfg, gfgdgdfgdhfgj
Reviewer did not try the product Profanity/Vulgar language Advertising (Vendor promotion, iHerb Coupons etc.) Marketing campaign (BzzAgent, Influenster etc.)