I got this eyeliner in brown about two months ago and I've been using it a couple of times a week since then. The first thing i noticed about this eyeliner was the pigmentation. It goes on very opaque at the first swipe and in a way I would never have expected such an inexpensive liner to do. The swatch on my hand stayed on until i used makeup remover to take it of, another very pleasant surprise.
Now to the not so good part of this review, and the reason to the 3 stars. I always have trouble opening this, even after talking all the build up out of the lid, and it's really an effort to get to the actual product. Also, on my eyes, this peels off in the weirdest way like no eyeliner ever has done to me before. Even if it stays on my hand all day, even through washing and scratching, on my eyes it seems to come off just by breathing on it, and i have to reapply it every 4-5 hours. Usually i find my eyeliner to be the longest lasting part of my makeup, but not with this one.
I won't repurchase this product, but you definitely get more than you pay for with this. I will use it up and i will kind of enjoy it, but when this boy is done, I'll move on to something else.