This review is for the solid version.
I hate to say it, but I'm slightly disappointed with this perfume. Not because of the scent - I've known and loved the Karma scent for a long time - but because of the wear time. When recently applied, it's a big and bold scent, but it fades much more quickly than I imagined it would. In fact, much more quickly than the Vanillary solid perfume, in my experience. At the end of the day I can't smell even a trace of it where I applied it to my wrists, for example. Sure, the tin makes it easy to stick in your bag and reapply during the day, but it's still a bit disappointing.
Speaking of the tin, though: I love it. As I mentioned, I also have the Vanillary one, but I've had it for a while, so it's in the little stick/tub format instead. There's all kinds of problems with that one, melting product and a whole lot of mess being the main ones. But this tin is really convenient. Unlike the tin that they used to (still do?) sell lip tints and lip balms in that are a pain to get the lid off, this lid simply screws on and off. Also, it's a vegan perfume, which is great in and of itself.
I'm not opposed to trying more of Lush's solid perfumes, but if I want another Karma perfume in the future, I'll give the spray-on one a try instead.