I wouldn't expect something called "eye grease" to actually last on my lids all day, so the creasing came as no big surprise. I did manage to make it last the day somehow, creating a soft, smudged and smokey eye using Indigo, which is a sharp navy blue that looks incredible. Shame the CM line is no longer easy access at Sephora stores, as most of their products are really worth it. I'd buy this again if for no other reason than to create such soft eye looks with slick, fashionable colours. Consistency of this is thick (not like Vaseline to me, but heavier than your average cream shadow), and a light hand will go a long way in creating the perfect look.