Healthy Volume Mascara

It is nothing special but it is nothing terrible either. Too much work to get volume with repeated coats although I appreciate the "No clump" thing because it doesn' clump....The brush is HUGE ,look out for that!!! I'm still trying to figure it all out before dumping it in the trash...because, I'm trying so many many other mascaras out there, I confess: I use multiple mascaras and so then, have a problem removing the waterproof from the non-waterproof...but, I cannot find a good use for this Neutragena one...Anyone else have this issue? Thx.

Fluttery Separated Lashes – This mascara is wonderful and my only complaint is the huge brush. My goal was to find a volumizing mascara that didn’t flake with a nylon brush. This mascara gave me length, volume and excellent separation. Most importantly, this didn’t flake at all which is AMAZING. The wand is so oversized that it makes it a little difficult to manueuver without getting product around your eye. If the wand was smaller this would be a perfect mascara for me. I have thin, short lashes and this made them look so feathery and full.

Good mascara, for people who don't like to clump it on. I am one of those people, so this was perfect.

My favorite ds mascara. It gives a natural look thats easy to remove, doesn't irritate my eyes or flake everywhere. It's pretty much the only mascara i use now.

I wish i could give this mascara 5 stars but it has one fatal flaw - it doesn't wear long enough!. I love the brush (hate those stupid plastic bristle brushes), love the way it applies (no clumps, natural looking), but after about 8 hours, I have racoon eyes

First impression review: Digging this mascara. Decided to try it after feeling like my usual was leaving my lashes a bit crunchy lately. Not sure the "infused olive" does anything to nourish the little lash hairs, but my lashes do feel softer with this mascara on compared to other mascara. I have Black, and it has good pigmentation. Not shiny, inky black but rather a soft black. To me "volume" means thick/many lashes and this delivers on that, in a real looking way. My lashes look plentiful, long-ish and hold curl well with this mascara. It's definitely not a false lash result, but delivers a volume-boosted, natural looking finish. My only minor quibble is that the formula is on the drier side. The packaging is fine and the wand is a bigger one, a straight bristle brush that works well for the formula. Hits every lash and builds them up without clumping. No spider lash, flakes, or smears, even on long, hot summer days. Removes with face wash and a little bit of makeup eraser without a fight. UPDATE: Dropped down to a 2 score. This formula got so dry within a week of use that I ended up throwing it away. It was starting to create crumbles, make my lashes stick together, and even become too dry to apply smoothly. What a waste.

I originally used this mascara several years back and hated it. This was back in high school when I was obsessed with wearing tons of mascara and only liked it if it was clump central (thank God for growing out of that stage). I was at Walmart and near the makeup section and something drew me to try this again...so glad I did! Beautiful volume, no clumps, and it feels so good on my lashes. It doesn't feel like I'm wearing mascara, but my lashes look so good....I'm so glad I decided to give this another go.

This is the best mascara I've tried since CoverGirl's Clump Crusher stopped playing nice with my sensitive eyes and contact lenses (it's a great mascara, just not for me anymore). I can be at work all day and spend an evening at an "optional" training without my eyes stinging when I get home. The brush is a standard large-ish straight brush, which might not be your thing if you like curved brushes. That said, the brush is big enough to get all of my lashes, and if you curl your lashes anyway then it's a non-issue. I typically only use one coat, but upon trying a second coat I didn't see any extra clumping or sticking as long as I don't brush it on too fast. There's little-to-no fallout when I get home from a day at work (standard school day plus morning/afternoon meetings, so an average of 9 hours), and it comes off with a makeup wipe. I do need to give my lashes some extra attention to get all of the makeup off, which I suppose is a testament to this mascara's staying power. If you've got finicky eyes and/or contact lenses, I've had good success with this mascara. Would buy again.

I love love love this mascara. I have tried some of the expensive ones and always com back to Neutrogena. I never flakes, smudges or ends up under my eyes, My eyelashes are very thin now that I'm older and this mascara really helps them looks like more, I only wish it was available in brown for blondes and redheads.

I thought this was just an okay mascara. Was not great but it did darken and add some volume to my lashes. The problems I did have were 1. I prefer mascaras that make my lashes look long but this was not terrible 2. it smudged under my eyes.