It sounds to me like at least some of your redness may be exacerbated by such ++
It might be your skincare because the ones you tried are light...
Cakey under eyes, IMO, is either a result of using too much concealer, foundation, powder or some+
Tips and list of stick blushes: ++
OK, here's some ideas... ++
To try ++
What's your skincare/prep like? It really makes or breaks how your makeup looks and ++