Overall rating
3.7
Created with Sketch.
65%
would repurchase
3.7
Created with Sketch.
Overall rating
65%
would repurchase

Latest Eyeko Reviews

Black Magic Liquid Eyeliner
5.0
Created with Sketch.

2 months ago

I first got this in my Ipsy bag. It remains my favorite and I've repurchased the full size several times. It doesn't have the most intense, immediate color saturation as some, but you can achieve great color payoff by going back over a few times. I simply haven't found another eyeliner pen that lets me get precise straight lines like this one. I can get a great wing and really fine-tune it, without dragging or jerky lines. The marker works for a long time (months) even after being applied over glittery eyeshadows. It lasts all night, stays in place, and doesn't bleed or peel/flake off, even after sweating and dancing. I can apply false lashes on top and they don't lift. This is a really nice product.

Black Magic Liquid Eyeliner
5.0
Created with Sketch.

2 months ago

I first got this in my Ipsy bag. It remains my favorite and I've repurchased the full size several times. It doesn't have the most intense, immediate color saturation as some, but you can achieve great color payoff by going back over a few times. I simply haven't found another eyeliner pen that lets me get precise straight lines like this one. I can get a great wing and really fine-tune it, without dragging or jerky lines. The marker works for a long time (months) even after being applied over glittery eyeshadows. It lasts all night, stays in place, and doesn't bleed or peel/flake off, even after sweating and dancing. I can apply false lashes on top and they don't lift. This is a really nice product.


Black Magic Liquid Eyeliner
3.0
Created with Sketch.

2 months ago

I have this eyeliner for 6 months and still hasn't dried out! So, I am amazed just by this! The COLOR is black but definitely not the blackest I have come across. For example, the Physician's Formula Eye Booster Eyeliner in Ultra Black and the L'oreal - Flash Cat Eye in the same color are waaaaaaaaay blacker and pigmented than this. I have oily eyelids and super watery eyes and this smudges after 5 hours. The ones that don't smudge on me AT ALL and LAST ALL DAY LONG are the Physician's Formula, the KVD- Tattoo Eyeliner and the Fenty Flyliner. It has a brush tip that helps you easily draw a line with no issues at all, very similar to the eyeliners I have already mentioned from Physician's Formula, KVD, L'oreal. So all in all, this is an AVERAGE eyeliner due to smudging and the level of pigmentation but it's definitely not one of those eyeliners that after 3 months has dried out and needs a replacement, like Celine Dion says it goes on and on....AND ON!:D I wouldn't repurchase it but I use it and I enjoy it on days when I wear my make up for few hours only. I wouldn't recommend it to people that have super oily eyelids or watery eyes.

Black Magic Liquid Eyeliner
3.0
Created with Sketch.

2 months ago

I have this eyeliner for 6 months and still hasn't dried out! So, I am amazed just by this! The COLOR is black but definitely not the blackest I have come across. For example, the Physician's Formula Eye Booster Eyeliner in Ultra Black and the L'oreal - Flash Cat Eye in the same color are waaaaaaaaay blacker and pigmented than this. I have oily eyelids and super watery eyes and this smudges after 5 hours. The ones that don't smudge on me AT ALL and LAST ALL DAY LONG are the Physician's Formula, the KVD- Tattoo Eyeliner and the Fenty Flyliner. It has a brush tip that helps you easily draw a line with no issues at all, very similar to the eyeliners I have already mentioned from Physician's Formula, KVD, L'oreal. So all in all, this is an AVERAGE eyeliner due to smudging and the level of pigmentation but it's definitely not one of those eyeliners that after 3 months has dried out and needs a replacement, like Celine Dion says it goes on and on....AND ON!:D I wouldn't repurchase it but I use it and I enjoy it on days when I wear my make up for few hours only. I wouldn't recommend it to people that have super oily eyelids or watery eyes.

Black Magic Mascara (Curved Brush)
2.0
Created with Sketch.
from

6 months ago

The consistency is very wet for the first month so everytime I had mascara all over my lids, impossible to get off, no matter how careful I was. After that the mascara started to hold the curve quite ok, but still I'm not very impressed with this. Will use the tube but unlikely will be buying again.

Black Magic Mascara (Curved Brush)
2.0
Created with Sketch.
from

6 months ago

The consistency is very wet for the first month so everytime I had mascara all over my lids, impossible to get off, no matter how careful I was. After that the mascara started to hold the curve quite ok, but still I'm not very impressed with this. Will use the tube but unlikely will be buying again.