14 Best Eye Shadows for Fair-Medium skin

Pin It

Based on 42236 reviews of 8797 eye shadows from 342 brands, written by MakeupAlley users with fair-medium skin, these are the 14 best eye shadows for fair-medium skin

Urban Decay Toasted

4.8

155 reviews

96% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

When I told the sales clerk at Sephora that I wanted something new in an eyeshadow from Urban Decay, but not a brown or a neutral, I was dismayed when she immediatel

MORE >>
bareMinerals Glimmer- Queen Tiffany

4.7

98 reviews

91% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

Queen Tiffany should be a staple in every makeup bag! It's one of those shades that looks stunning on any eye color. I always get compliments on how pretty my eyes

MORE >>
NYX Professional Makeup Single Eye Shadow - Root Beer

4.7

94 reviews

91% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

I LOVE nyx products and even though this is a great colour, beware, its not for everyone.. infact its not for a lot of people. Its looks scrumptious in the pot but w

MORE >>
MAC Satin - Coquette

4.7

115 reviews

95% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

Coquette means what? Subtlety? No, it means Flirty, although maybe in a young, girlish way. At any rate here's another go to neutral, but lighter than all the oth

MORE >>
MAC Pigment in Vanilla

4.7

621 reviews

91% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

DESCRIPTION OF ME Asian with a warm complexion (C3-C4 in MAC) with strong yellow undertones and some peach. Black hair. Very oily skin that is prone to breako

MORE >>
Barry M Dazzle Dust

4.6

100 reviews

98% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

The two users below have done a great job of describing this great little product. The colour range is astounding and the quality's high, though the texture varies f

MORE >>
wet n wild Color Icon Eyeshadow Single - Brulee

4.6

429 reviews

91% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

Another "Hells yes I would buy again" item. It evens out redness, purpleness, blueness, and "Man, I slept like CRAP!"-ness on my upper eyelid. And under my lower

MORE >>
L'Oreal Paris Infallible Shadow- Iced Latte (888)

4.6

86 reviews

91% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

If you're looking for a drugstore dupe for UD's Sin (or Stila's Kitten)...This is close, but no cigar. But don't stop reading, because there is a good chance you may

MORE >>
MAC Veluxe Pearl - Antiqued

4.6

147 reviews

88% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

This shade has replaced Mulch as my absolute MAC favorite. It is an absolutely gorgeous rust/copper/brown Veluxe Pearl that applies like a dream. It really brings ou

MORE >>
MAC Satin - Soba

4.5

178 reviews

89% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

I have over 60 mac eyeshadows, this one is my hoily grail. Because with only using that I shadow, 1- I can create a daily look when I applied it to all over my li

MORE >>
MAC Satin - Cork

4.5

203 reviews

90% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

I uploaded a photo and linked it and the bottom of this review. I was using UD Buck in my crease and I read endless reviews noting that it's a dupe for MAC Cork. Saw

MORE >>
NYX Professional Makeup Ultra Pearl Mania

4.5

156 reviews

91% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

These were my very first pigments ever in life. I got the whole set on ebay for $25. There are 24 colors (some I swapped away, so there are only 22 here). These are

MORE >>
MAC Frost - Humid

4.5

315 reviews

85% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

Women with brown, olive, tan, or yellow-based skin: green is NOT your enemy! I'm so surprised at the number of women who are afraid of green eyeshadows...even at th

MORE >>
COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers - Mink

4.3

149 reviews

87% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

I've been buying this shade for what feels like over 10 years, and I hope they never stop making it! It's beautiful, a very versatile pink champagne shade that someh

MORE >>

Popular Eye Shadows

SEE MORE >>

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google
  • Pinterest

Back to Top