16 Best Eye Shadows for Fair-Medium skin

Pin It

Based on 42060 reviews of 8728 eye shadows from 340 brands, written by MakeupAlley users with fair-medium skin, these are the 16 best eye shadows for fair-medium skin

Urban Decay Toasted

4.8

155 reviews

96% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

When I told the sales clerk at Sephora that I wanted something new in an eyeshadow from Urban Decay, but not a brown or a neutral, I was dismayed when she immediatel

MORE >>
MAC Satin - Coquette

4.7

116 reviews

95% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

Coquette means what? Subtlety? No, it means Flirty, although maybe in a young, girlish way. At any rate here's another go to neutral, but lighter than all the oth

MORE >>
NYX Single Eye Shadow - Root Beer

4.7

94 reviews

91% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

I LOVE nyx products and even though this is a great colour, beware, its not for everyone.. infact its not for a lot of people. Its looks scrumptious in the pot but w

MORE >>
Milani Java Bean (18)

4.7

180 reviews

92% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

PICTURES AND SWATCHES INCLUDED. Please click Continued for full review.
Price: 1, Packaging: 4, Rebuy: Yes
This is my HG brown e/s because it's ridiculou

MORE >>
Bare Escentuals Glimmer- Queen Tiffany

4.7

99 reviews

90% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

Queen Tiffany should be a staple in every makeup bag! It's one of those shades that looks stunning on any eye color. I always get compliments on how pretty my eyes

MORE >>
MAC Pigment in Vanilla

4.7

620 reviews

91% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

DESCRIPTION OF ME Asian with a warm complexion (C3-C4 in MAC) with strong yellow undertones and some peach. Black hair. Very oily skin that is prone to breako

MORE >>
Barry M Dazzle Dust

4.6

100 reviews

98% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

The two users below have done a great job of describing this great little product. The colour range is astounding and the quality's high, though the texture varies f

MORE >>
Wet 'n' Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow Single - Brulee

4.6

427 reviews

91% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

Another "Hells yes I would buy again" item. It evens out redness, purpleness, blueness, and "Man, I slept like CRAP!"-ness on my upper eyelid. And under my lower

MORE >>
MAC Pigment in Violet

4.6

212 reviews

89% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

i'll be the first to admit it - i have a serious purple "affliction". i have SOOO many...But it is hard to find what i call neutral purples for my skin tone (ones th

MORE >>
L'Oreal Paris Infallible Shadow- Iced Latte (888)

4.6

85 reviews

92% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

If you're looking for a drugstore dupe for UD's Sin (or Stila's Kitten)...This is close, but no cigar. But don't stop reading, because there is a good chance you may

MORE >>
MAC Veluxe Pearl - Antiqued

4.5

146 reviews

88% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

This shade has replaced Mulch as my absolute MAC favorite. It is an absolutely gorgeous rust/copper/brown Veluxe Pearl that applies like a dream. It really brings ou

MORE >>
MAC Satin - Soba

4.5

177 reviews

89% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

I really didn't care for this color. I'm NC15 and felt that Soba is too dark for me to wear packed on the whole lid during daytime. After playing around with it for

MORE >>
MAC Satin - Cork

4.5

202 reviews

90% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

I uploaded a photo and linked it and the bottom of this review. I was using UD Buck in my crease and I read endless reviews noting that it's a dupe for MAC Cork. Saw

MORE >>
NYX Ultra Pearl Mania

4.5

156 reviews

91% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

These were my very first pigments ever in life. I got the whole set on ebay for $25. There are 24 colors (some I swapped away, so there are only 22 here). These are

MORE >>
MAC Frost - Humid

4.4

314 reviews

85% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

Women with brown, olive, tan, or yellow-based skin: green is NOT your enemy! I'm so surprised at the number of women who are afraid of green eyeshadows...even at th

MORE >>
Cover Girl Eye Enhancers - Mink

4.3

149 reviews

87% would repurchase

BEST REVIEWexpand

I've been buying this shade for what feels like over 10 years, and I hope they never stop making it! It's beautiful, a very versatile pink champagne shade that someh

MORE >>

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google
  • Pinterest

Back to Top