I found this on the bottom shelf at my local walmart. I bought it for all the promising things advertised on the packaging, though I was a little skeptical. I think it's been on the bottom shelf for quite some time, because my tube seems rather dry, but it can be used nevertheless. When I actually tried the product, I went into shock! Being asian, my lashes are short and straight, on a downward slope. But with marcelle,my lashes look thicker, longer, and have more of a lift. Now I've tried a lot of mascaras, from rimmel's sexy curves to dior in diorshow unlimited, but I dont think any of them have given me results like marcelle did! Definitely buy again.