Didn't work for me, it turned flaky on my skin even after using additional moisturizer and primer. To heavy and cake-y for me.
But this is the first mascara I've found that absolutely does not smudge. Plus since I found it at Grocery Outlet for $2.50 it was a true steal! It does't thicken as much as others but that is a mild trade off for an all-day wear, even overnight with no raccoon eyes. It is great at lengthening and is build-able to get some thickness. This is my new HG mascara.