I got this in charcoal along with the brush. The pot is beyond tiny and is a lot for $22.00. I could overlook that if I loved the product, but this gel eyeliner really baffled me. It was difficult to apply because it had to be layered to show up dark enough. I like some shimmer in my eyeliners, but this had too much sparkle for me. However, my biggest complaint and surprise was the amount of fallout I got. There were black flakes all over my face. I couldn't believe it! Since I bought it on ebay (it didn't look old or dried out), I couldn't return it. I thought I would save it and give it away, but then decided I wouldn't even want anyone else to have it, so I threw it away. For me, this was the worst gel eyeliner I ever tried - maybe it was a bad batch because I cannot believe anyone would like this if they tried what I had.
I just bought this at Sephora and have to agree with many of the other reviewers, that it is the WORST eyeliner I have ever used. I was wondering why the tip crumbled when the sales person put it on her hand to demonstrate. When I mentioned that, she said something like she was being too hard with it. First off, without having a pointy tip (that only lasts for a second), how can anyone expect to get a precision, even line with an uneven flat top? When I tried to wing out the corner of my eye, the entire thing crumbled. The box says to avoid "over advancing" the point because it could break..Seriously, who can be bothered with such a finicky product. I am glad that some of the ladies have had some success with it though. Bringing it back for sure.