I was on the rush for a pencil eyeliner, and doing little research online I came up with this baby. Unfortunately, it wasn't what I was hoping to get. The color and pigmentation is VERY good. It glides on like a dream. I use this on my lower lash line. However, even if the pigmentation is brilliant, my main concern is the staying power. Eyeliner for me creases like CRAZY. It is because i have a small crease on the outer part of my eye so eyeliner likes to.. build up there. Also partly because I have oily/watery eyes. That being said, it is not the eyeliner for me. It's a wonderful product but it's just not for me. If you perhaps have a drier eye area then this could work fantastically for you. I dropped a lippie mostly because the product dried out! What use is it to me when the fantastic thing about it is the smoothness, and it suddenly dries up on me! Will not repurchase purely for the fact that I know there are better (and cheaper) eyeliners out there. I have also just dipped my foot into the water of eyeliners so I have a lot of experimenting to do!
I don't see why there is so much hype about this. The colour selection isn't great, the formula is crazy thick, and please, even the famously known staying power isn't 'fab'. I was at the zoo and the temperature was probably 30. At the end of the day, i put my hand on my face and when i take a look, all my foundation came off! what the?! I powdered too... I could only imagine for humid areas. And I have normal skin! The formula is pretty gross. It's thick and streaky and will not blend beautifully. I used my ELF flat top powder brush, and it looked pretty bad. Made my skin look cakey. *shivers* Coverage wasn't even full. Heavy medium coverage? Not worth it. Flawless skin? Not a chance. Mask on my face? Yeah. But i do have to give it some credit, my friend said my skin looked flawless, but honestly, she was 4 feet from me. Sigh.