really face shop? really? i mean i thought The Body Shop's Eye Definer was bad but this... it was like a dry marker. :( i mean i guess it's okay if you like "sheer eyeliner" (i don't think they're EVER supposed to be sheer, though) and all you want is to create an impression that you have thicker eyelashes, but otherwise, this is not cool. it really did look like i drew on my lids with a marker. the liner was thin, too liquid, and just flimsy.
i saw results by the third week of using this twice a day and now i have twice as many lashes as i used to. it hasn't actually made me grow new lashes, but it has kept prevented them from falling out for longer periods of time. however, it has made my lashes longer. i'm half-way through my second bottle already and i think i'll get some more. and i really hope L'Oreal doesn't discontinue this!