PROS: lovely color payoff, super creamy, does not smudge after it sets CONS: DO NOT WEAR THIS WITH UR CONACT LENSES! I had them on my upper lash line ( not water line) and it totally blurred up my lenses within 1-2 hours! It makes you feel like you got severe cataract. I tried washing my lenses but they just got blurry again! I had to go home early from a night out because I was literally blind :'( if it wasn't for my fiance I highly doubt I could make it home !