HG. I have quite long and thick ashes and hate to look too done up, so this is perfect! Buildable, natural, doesn't smudge or flake much. And the best part -- the brush comes out without too much on it!
Makes my eyelids itch and puff :(
I've been using the same tube since 2005, and I'm still only 3/4 through it. I love this stuff. People say it's too dry, but that's the point! It gives you a smooth, dry surface that shadows grip onto, preventing the gummy crease thing. I haven't tried UDPP, don't need to! THis stuff is tops.
I don't care that the packaging sucks, this is my HG. I have terrible undereye circles, but this formula is so pigmented without being drying htat I only need a light sweep with my concealer brush to disguise them. I don't even set with powder... I've had this for a month, using every day, and have used maybe 1/30 of the jar.
Great mascara, best I've ever tried. No flaking or smudging, but comes off easily... only 4 lippies because the packaging's not perfect. I'd prefer a smaller hole in the bottle so it isn't so clumpy the first few wears.