I really like this product. I used to wear eyeliner all the time, but after trying this, the dark boldness of it does the trick and emphasizes my eyes. So now I wear this and the MAC gel liner in black on my upper water line and occasionally some light eyeshadow, and voila, subtle makeup for a more natural everyday "I don't even have to try" look. Yeah, sometimes it does clump a little (just use a lash comb and it'll come right out), but it washes out easily and doesn't give me raccoon eyes even though I have fairly oily skin.
One of the best things that's ever happened to me, makeup-wise. At first I was worried because so many people were writing about how sticky it would be on your face and how it was only for people with dry skin, but I personally have oily skin and its perfectly fine. It gives you a deep rich healthy hue that powdered blushes can't begin to give and it isn't sticky after it dries ( I apply it with my fingers though). I'm acne prone and I haven't broke out after using it, not even a little and I'm not using any other acne med currently either. My skin used to be fairly colorless and dull, but this adds some much needed color and gives me a more youthful, less made up look. And the smell doesn't bother me at all, it's kind of nice.