Call me crazy, but I like all three of these lipglosses. The Holiday Red is a pretty much clear citrus-y scented gloss that goes on really watery to me. Never having tried Philosophy's Kiss Me balms before, I figured that's how they all are. The Peppermint Patty (lovely scent and taste) is a really sheer pink that goes on clear as well, but a lot thicker than the Holdiay Red, which I thought was kind of strange, but whatever. The Sugar Cookie is a frosty white that looks absoulutely horrid by itself, but when paired with a nudish berry lipstick/liner (I used Origins Matte Stick in Berry), it works wonders. It smells like this old lipgloss I used to have (True Colors in Hazelnut Creme or something... I forget), so it's kind of nostalgic for me. The taste however, isn't even anything near sugar cookies or any kind of thing you're supposed to eat. It tastes like plastic ass. The reason I gave it such a good rating was because I didn't pay for it, and they were all pretty nice and will probably last me forever.