I've been using this product for about five years now and I do like it, however will probably be looking for a new liquid liner shortly. I think it's been out of pure laziness I haven't changed sooner. It does its job but I do find that it smudges a little after about four or five hours and it sometimes stings my eyes when applying. The applicator is great - sturdy with a point on the tip which I find easy to create a wing with. It's definitely worth the price.