I love this mascara. It's not perfect and I haven't given it 5 stars out of 5 just because I haven't found the perfect mascara yet, but it really satisfies my needs. It's very light so it doesn't make your lashes heavy, but it's deeply black and liquid so it spreads perfectly. The brush allows to reach even the small, short lashes of the inner eye. You would need a curler before applying but otherwise it's perfect and I love the packaging. I'm definitely going to buy it again as long as the price is pretty cheap. Recommended for a "fan" effect on already medium-long lashes, especially if you don't want them to be too "fake" or thick.
I like this mascara even though it's not the best I've ever tried and I felt a little disappointed in the beginning. It does add volume and blackness to your lashes, but you would need a lash curler to emphatize the effect and there's too much product on the brush. I wouldn't buy it again just because I prefer other products of the same brand, but it isn't bad at all anyway!
This mascara is very interesting and the package is lovely, but it's not that special anyway. I like using the 1st look to define my lower lashes and to fill up the rest of the higher ones, after I've applied another mascara. Anyway it wouldn't be that bad used on all of them, but I don't think it's one of the best mascaras I've ever tried, it's good and it was very cheap but it doesn't make miracles. Probably won't purchase it again...
Maybe 4 out of 5 is a bit too much, but to be honest I am really strict. I would rate it between 3 and 4 (I'd never give 5 to any mascara I've tried yet). Anyway this is a great mascara if you're looking for clear, well defined, curved lashes. I don't think it makes miracles if you have very short or thin lashes, but I like it anyway. The final effect is natural but noticeable, it didn't clump my lashes at all, I'd say it's a bit liquid. It works even better with an eyelash curler. I think I'll purchase it again even though I'd like to try the other packages (waterproof, intense black and so on).