I love this mascara! It's the best that I have tried by far! The waterproof version of this I think has a better formula than the regular. It holds curl for the whole day and keeps my lashes thick and you can see them from a far. It is tough to get off but any waterproof mascara is. I would definitely recommend it.
I know tinted moisturizers aren't suppose to full coverage but this one didn't even have light coverage! It had no coverage at all! Also it felt sooooo greasy! My skin felt so gross with it on, I just wanted to wash my face! And it didn't make a difference to my skin. I would not recommend it.