So sad to see all of the negative reviews!! This is my absolute favorite mascara. I use this every day on top of whatever other mascara I am using at the time. It doesn't flake at all on my lashes. Gives good definition, length and volume. You really have to be light handed with this mascara and make sure to get rid of excess product on the brush. If you do this, it will not clump. That has been my experience, anyways. If Mac ever discontinued this mascara I would be devastated. I have used it for 4 years and wish to continue using it for many more.
I love the packaging of this product.. However, that is the only thing I loved about it. The formulation is hard to work with. It's cakey and made my skin look dry and dull. This product was the final straw for me in regards to maybelline foundations. When shopping for foundations I now walk straight past the maybelline section and move along to other brands. I really wanted to love this foundation, such a shame it was so terrible for me.
Packaging is great, nice pump. Good coverage and easy to blend. I bought this in C3 and it matches my skin tone perfectly. I set this foundation with Mac studiofix powder and it lasts all day. Very happy with this product and I will definitely repurchase.