the only tiff i have over this gloss are the decorative beads because sometimes they clog the opening.! otherwise i love that the gloss is in a tube, that it's ultra sticky for staying power, flavor && packaging.
unfortunatly not my holy grail, l'oreal voluminous curved brush still is. this mascara is the exact same, but it flaked for me. =( i have a bit more sense than to care about packaging, so i don't mind it isn't right phit.
stunning lip liner, especially when i pair with mac tanarama lipstick and c-thru lip glass. i'm a tan, platinum blonde with turquoise-ish eyes. i've never bought lip liner before but i figure this one's high-end and, thus, fairly highly priced, though well worth it as i use every day. love mac's packaging, clever and contemporary. will have to repurchase again and again, hoping they will not discontinue my holy grail.!!