|Would buy this product again.||82%|
Age: 36-43 Skin: Combination, Medium, Warm Hair: Black, Fine Eyes: Brown
This is amazing and i would repurchase for sure. I got this in dark brown, initially i thought it may not be dark enough, but it is an almost black dark brown, looks natural but defines. Black liners don't work for me so i usually go for dark brown.
Long-wearing, does not budge all day even though i have oily eyelids
Fine brush tip, very easy to use
More sanitary as you twist for more product to come out at the tip
Age: 18 & Under Skin: Oily, Medium, Warm Hair: Black, Straight, Medium Eyes: Black
One of the best liners I've used definitely!
I'm using the one darkest one BK999 and the pigment is great. The one I'm using has lasted me for months despite using it almost everyday for school. The brush however could be thinner to be able to create a more natural look. The twist of the pen also produces too much product sometimes if you just wish to touch up or need a little product.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Combination, Medium Hair: Brown Eyes: Brown
I first saw this from the beauty blog www.pinkpitstop.wordpress.com
I'm glad I did because it's a really good eyeliner! The line is precise and stays on the whole day :) I just wish you could precisely control the amount that comes out when you twist the bottom part. I always end up with too much for one eye.
Still, I would definitely buy this is in the future.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Other Hair: Other Eyes: Other
It applies very smoothly. The color is very opaque!
Age: 25-29 Skin: Normal, Fair-Medium Hair: Black Eyes: Brown
Bought this eye liner few months ago. Never try it.
Always use heavy rotation pencil eye liner, until last week start using MM eye liner.
This is the first time using liquid eye liner, very easy to use.
The colour is fab, very long lasting. Definitely will buy again XD
Age: 25-29 Skin: Combination, Fair-Medium Hair: Black Eyes: Black
I bought this eyeliner 4 years ago and since then never looked back. I had some problems with the black colored ones (the pigments didn't really run well with the solvent so shake well) but the brown and black-green ones have never disappointed me.
I even use this for tightlining and never had a problem with it smudging. It does flake off, but on my super oily lids, it never ever gave me panda eyes. Just how oily are my lids? Well, I've tried all sorts of pencils and never did one stay on for an hour(Chanel ones to cheap Emily ones). I've tried gel as well and those came off within 2 hours (Kate, Maybelline, Bobbi Brown). This is the ONLY liner that works in Singapore's heat and humidity.
Although it stays on pretty well, cleaning it off is not a problem at all. :D best of all, if you make a mistake, just wait for it to dry completely before q-tipping the mistake off. It is kinda pricey, but one liner lasts forever. If you find it hard to draw directly, try cleaning off some excess on the back of your hand. Use it at an angle - it makes drawing a nice line so much easier. The inability to smudge with this eyeliner does limit so makeup styles though, but hey, when you have lids as oily as me, well, you just work with what you have. :D
Age: 19-24 Skin: Combination, Fair, Cool Hair: Black, Straight, Fine Eyes: Brown
This used to be something like the high end brands eyeliner. It delivers high pigmented and long lasting colour. The soft brush allows the work to be much easier. No affords are taken to apply on even for very thin eyeliner. I liked that one which comes in blackest black. It is hard to find something like that which will not hurt your purse much in Malaysia. However, it doesn't have high survival skills when it is touched with sweats and liquid. But it also means it is easily removed with remover. The price may be slightly pricey for a drugstore liquid eyeliner but it was worthy. Now it delivers much more watery and less black liners. And that is why I have stopped looking for it again. It is priced about RM50 and one can last about 3 months if is used daily. It is available at any Majolica Majorca counter.
Age: 25-29 Skin: Combination, Fair, Neutral Hair: Red, Wavy, Fine Eyes: Green
I put '3' on price because it was given to me as a present so I don't know what was paid for it.
THAT SAID. I love this! The click-up option helps make it easier to apply, to me. I was sent a pearly black shade that I really, really like. This is so much easier than I remember "pen" liquid liners to be when I tried them years ago. I've been using fluidline or cake liners for a long time because I always had so much trouble putting on liquid from a pen-style applicator... but I have no problem with this!! It's easy to make cat eyes with this, it stays on all day, and the colour goes on true.
it was also not as hard to take off as some other eyeliners I've tried, which is a plus in my opinion. I won't say "HG" because I really want to try the Dolly Wink liner, but i'm really impressed.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Combination, Fair, Neutral Hair: Brunette, Straight, Medium Eyes: Hazel
My HG liquid eyeliner. Easy to apply for cat eyes, lovely dark black colour, doesn't smudge, fake or fade. Mine has lasted a long time and I have bought a spare one and will buy another one when I go back to Hong Kong. The packaging is cute, but not childish. Better than Lancome, YSL and drugstore liquid eyeliners. Takes getting use to the twist up applicator at first, but love, love, love this product. Wish it was available in the UK.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Combination, Medium Hair: Black Eyes: Black
It is quite ok for me until i found my current dolly wink liner because it has a cons: it will turn into 'eraser dust' after sometime and i guess it is because of the sweat and sebum..not so long lasting but very pigmented..but it is not my type..lol
Age: 44-55 Skin: Sensitive, Fair-Medium Hair: Brunette Eyes: Brown
I had purchased this eyeliner in BK999 in black going on the reviews on this site as I was looking for a perfect liquid eyeliner but I was somewhat disappointed.
The colour was slightly shiny black (not matt) which was sometimes a bit too watery and upon application I had to go over the line to deepen the colour, also because of the shine it was difficult to see where the eyeliner had been applied. If a mistake is made the eyeliner is difficult to fix as it flakes off when you try to correct with a cotton bud.
But having said that, the consistency of the liquid was relatively smooth and the pen easy to use to create a cat/winged eye look.
Once applied though I found the line creased and flaked off easily especially in the corners of the eye pretty much straight away and did not stay on. This liquid eyeliner could be good for beginners as it is easy to apply with the pen but overall the quality is not the best.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Combination, Fair Hair: Black Eyes: Brown
To be very honest, i got this in BK999 just because I was attracted to the packaging (it had the best packaging in the whole drug store here in my country).
It took me awhile to get used to applying (as it is my first liquid eyeliner). But after I had gotten used to it, MY GOODNESS, ITS SO EASY to apply and it doesn't require alot to have the effect that's satisfactory.
The best thing is, I wore it in the morning, went for a rock concert, and it only began flaking out after the concert which is pretty understandable as people tend to sweat like crazy.So I would say that the staying power is FANTASTIC.(its a japanese product)
but there is something I would like to mention, I wore it during a holiday overseas where it was winter and pretty cold and it started flaking faster than usual when I'm in my country (where the weather is warm and humid all year round). I don't know if the weather could affect its staying power, but I thought I should mention it.
Saw some comments saying that the liquid goes of when applying second time, it's because you need to wait for it to dry a lil then reapply . It should be ok.
Unless I can find something very similar to this (and available in my country), I will continue using this. And I also recommend their waterproof mascara. For me, when i use the mascara, people tend to ask why I wear faux lashes. and it doesn't smudge AT ALL. it's definitely a concert makeup for the eyes :)
Age: 18 & Under Skin: Normal, Fair, Cool Hair: Brown, Wavy, Fine Eyes: Brown
I absolutely LOVE this eyeliner!
I have this in BK920 which is a glittery black and I use it everyday, it's been about 5 months since I bought it and I am almost finished but it is definitely good value for money!
Easy to apply, and mess free because of the twist applicator, you twist it once, at most twice, and the product comes through the brush. However, for me, after 7-8 hours it does chip off in some places but it might just be my oily eyelids.
Definitely reccommend to everyone!
Age: 19-24 Skin: Acne-prone, Medium Hair: Black Eyes: Brown
This eyeliner is good! It doesn't smudge and doesn't even need a makeup remover to remove. By just using wet cotton tips, the makeup gets removed easily. If I draw the line wrongly, I can use my finger to wipe it off without getting the smudgey look.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Dry, Fair-Medium Hair: Brown Eyes: Brown
I have this product in BK920 which they describe on the site as pearl black. I have given this liquid liner a 5 as I haven't found something to fault it on yet. It doesn't smudge over 10+ hours even with a visit to the gym, it doesn't irritate my eyes, the brush tip does genuinely make liquid liner application easier (I tend to struggle with short tips) and you get a reasonable amount for the price of approx £10. You only need one twist, two at the most if the tip is dry to get enough liquid, not sure why the reviewer below me had problems with this. When there is the right amount of liquid you won't see it spill out the top of the brush, you should just notice the brush widen a touch with the liner liquid coming through, that's enough to use for your first eye, and then I do one more twist to get enough for the second. I really like the colour range from MJ, I would definitely consider getting some other colours. like the other reviewers said don't just go for standard black, they have such a beautiful range available it's worth trying them! I normally use a brush and cake liner that needs water, so I like this liner for quick day use when I'm not near a sink. Although the hard lines of liquid liner don't normally suit me I find I can choose with this to go pencil finish or liquid, if I use more/put it on more thickly with the side of the brush it gets the hard liquid line, if I use the tip of the brush to get a lighter application it makes a softer line like my laura mercier water based cake liner.
Age: 18 & Under Skin: Combination, Fair-Medium Hair: Black Eyes: Black
This was my second liquid liner, i thought it would impress me but it did not. I'll start with the pros.
1. This brush is very fine, you can actually create the shape, wing or whatever you want.
2. Wont smudge ( i guess ? )
For the cons
1. I had a very very hard time dispensing the products. I had to twist this stuff for round 3 or 4 times as it didn't worked when i twist for 2 times. ( when i twist, i always shake this thing, but i didn't will it help in dispensing the product or not, in my case, it didn't )
2. When the liquid comes out, its too much for one eye!!!
3. The color is not very intense, i got this in bk999 or something. And when you go through the same area again to make it thicker or more intense, the liquid would just disappear. Just like when you write something on the whiteboard using the marker. The ink will disappear sometimes when you go through the area again.
Overall, i've tossed it away. I don't really trust pen liner right now. This liner only gave me pleasant memories for 2 out of around 8 or 9 times. Thats around 20 to 25%
Age: 19-24 Skin: Acne-prone, Medium, Cool Hair: Brunette, Straight, Fine Eyes: Brown
My first liquid liner and I LOVE it. It's smudge-proof but yet it's pretty easy to remove. The brush is awesome, it's makes making the cat-eyes line pretty easy. You could be dramatic/ subtle with the brush.The packaging is nice too and it's fairly small you could put it in your small purse (just in case you want to do some touch up on-the-go). I don't really like the gel liner that have separate brush, it's not convenient for on-the-go.
The price is okay (almost the same with other drugstore brands such as Revlon, Maybelline or L'oreal) and the color range is quite wide.
It's my HG liquid liner!
Age: 25-29 Skin: Acne-prone, Medium Hair: Black Eyes: Brown
My "go-to" for perfectly applied eyeliner. Dramatic or subtle, this pen can do it and it will do it with precision. The best feature is the flexible bristle tip which is almost exactly like a Pantone calligraphy pen. This means you can create thick or thin lines with the lightest touch. Ever imagined you could create the perfect cat eye flick without even trying? Now you can!
Washes away without a hassle, which is really important to me. Smudge proof and I don't experience the flaking that others have talked about.
I've had the black pen for nearly 8 months now and no signs of drying. It can be tricky to use initially if you don't shake properly or over-click.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Other Hair: Other Eyes: Other
I've always had trouble finding a good liquid liner that won't melt off my face - and this one does a pretty good job. Recently travelled around asia and stole this from my mom's makeup drawer. Although it isn't like MAC liquidlast, this last all day and doesn't smudge just like its advertised. Bought 5 more from watson's. The best thing about this is its packaging. Its pretty, the brush is stiff but SO easy to control, and doesn't dry out fast. Only drawback is if you twist it too much, the liquid comes out in drops.
Age: 25-29 Skin: Normal, Fair Hair: Brown Eyes: Brown
I have this in 5 colors total. Today I will be reviewing BR601 since it is the color I've used most, as I use the others I will update my review.
Packaging: this is a liquid liner in pen packaging. It has a thin stiff brush applicator and a twist up application system. This style of packaging allows me to apply my liner precisely and let's me control the thickness of my liner completely. The only weakness I find in the packaging is that you have to twist the bottom to use the product, sometimes I have to twist it many times for anything to come out, sometimes just a couple of clicks sends a huge glob of product out! It reminds me of the stila lip glaze packaging actually. This isn't really something that can be controlled with this style of liner and the pros for me far outweigh the cons.
Formula: the consistency of the liner is a thin liquid. This is my favorite formula by far. I can apply my liner quickly and smoothly. It dries fast enough to not smudge yet not too fast where I can't work with it. It is also smudge proof. Even after a long day I do not have raccoon eyes, it stays put! It is kind of like paint that sits on top of your skin, if you rub your eye it flakes off.
Color: BR601 is a bronzey dark brown. It has a bit of metallic shine to it if you look at it from an angle.
Price and availability: this brand is not readily available in the US. I ordered it on eBay and paid $21 for it though it retails for a bit less.
Overall: I love it! Makes applying eyeliner mistake proof! I purchased 2 colors for my sister and she loves it too!