Maybelline • Superstay • Concealers
|Would buy this product again.||67%|
Age: 19-24 Skin: Dry, Medium Hair: Brunette Eyes: Brown
So i love this product because I spend money and time trying to find the one concealer that would stay on and now I'm proud to say I DID!!!! It's great gives me great coverage stays put and a tiny bit is all u need otherwise it can look very caky so use I little bit blend it fast and good cause it gets dry fast. When is dry and done do not tuch or is going to look caky and very dry under the eye but it's a great product Im going to keep buying it and so yeah I do recommend it :)!!!!!!
Age: 44-55 Skin: Dry, Fair, Neutral Hair: Blond, Straight, Fine Eyes: Green
I've tried many concelaers in my time and this is one of a few that have worked for me. The price is great, around 6 dollars in Target.... covers up what I need covered without giving me that cakey look under my eyes, stays put all day, and just brightens up the under eye area. Being past 50 I thought that this concealer wasn't going to work because I do have those nasty fine lines but I was so pleasantly surprised.
Age: 44-55 Skin: Dry, Fair Hair: Brunette Eyes: Blue
Very nice concealer for a drugstore price. I bought this after watching several YT reviews & was intrigued. Prior to it, I'd been using Bobbi Brown's corrector, which is very creamy & a good color match for me, but alas, not enough coverage. For what I paid for the BB, I was open to finding a cheaper alternative that worked as well, if not better. I bought this in the shade Cream. I don't like that that it sets up so fast (you must work it in very quickly) but other than that, I'm pleased. I now use this over the Bobbi corrector - yeah I know-- 2 steps :( -- but I get long-lasting coverage that isn't cakey... finally! I would repurchase this concealer.
Age: 25-29 Skin: Acne-prone, Olive Hair: Brunette, Straight, Fine Eyes: Black
When I first put this on I thought I had found my HG concealer. My hyperpigmentation scars were covered and my skin looked flawless. Then l looked at my face in a lighted mirror and the truth was revealed: not only was it super cakey, but it seemed to settle into every single pore and made them look HUGE. It looked even worse in the sunlight. It's also pretty hard to work with as it dries super fast. Plus, they only have 4 shades to choose from. I'm still using it to offset the dark yellow of the Mary Kay concealer I recently bought in my ongoing quest for the perfect concealer, but even combined with that it still sinks into my pores. I really wanted to like this concealer, but I definitely won't be buying it again.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Combination, Tan Hair: Brown Eyes: Brown
I gave this a try since the reviews were so great and the sound of an oil-free long lasting concealer that covers fully drew my attention and so did the price. At Ulta there was a buy 1 get 1 sale so i got this and something else. I have to say I was impressed! Ive tried so many different concealers since I am obsessed with concealer and this one goes on so creamy but delivers great coverage. Also, it's hard to find a concealer that won't break you out and this one doesn't! It's also fantastic for dark circles! I'm going to try the Age Rewind double ended one next!
Age: 30-35 Skin: Normal, Medium, Cool Hair: Blond, Straight, Fine Eyes: Hazel
While I adore my MAC and Time Balm, I am always looking for something better, cheaper and easier to purchase. I picked this up in Medium Beige as Maybelline was BOGO 50% off and I had gone in to buy the primer. This color matches my NW25-30 skin near perfectly and applies seamlessly. It does last 14+ hours on me without getting cakey or creasing. Doesn't make me breakout and covers slight imperfections nicely. I find I do have to blend this in quickly otherwise it becomes difficult to work with, and while the doe-foot applicator is convenient and "hygienic" (it's just me using it!!!) I prefer pots because I use my own brush. I would give it a 4 and a half as it is near perfect...but alas it doesn't quite get that status. I just like having this to use for my everyday look as I don't have to use up my expensive stuff. This is a great concealer and I will be repurchasing this one again.
Age: Unknown Skin: Normal, Fair Hair: Brown, Straight, Fine Eyes: Brown
Awesome concealer, replaced my former HG, Revlon Colorstay.
Age: 18 & Under Skin: Dry, Fair-Medium, Warm Hair: Brunette, Wavy, Fine Eyes: Brown
It was an okay product. It had decent coverage. But, I had two very big problems with it. First problem: They have a very limited color selection so I could only use it under my eyes because it was too light for the rest of my face. (I got it in cream. The next darkest color was way too dark.) Which is a big bummer for me, because I'm looking for a concealer I can use for my under eye bags as well as blemishes and redness. Second problem: It dries SO QUICKLY. Usually when I put on my concealer, I dot it over the places I need it, then blend it out. With this concealer, I can't do that. Once I put it on my skin, I have to quickly blend it out before it dries and becomes impossible to even move around. Also, it can look extremely cakey. Usually when I wear this concealer, I have to dot a little bit of my foundation over it to make it not look as cakey. Overall, I don't think I'll be buying this product again.
Age: 30-35 Skin: Combination, Medium, Cool Hair: Black, Wavy, Fine Eyes: Black
I love this concealer! I have tried so many high end and drugstore concealers. My biggest request is that they not emphasize the baby fine lines under my eyes. I use Clarins Instant Smooth primer under all of my concealers, so it's important that any concealer I use play nice with the Clarin's (MUFE and NARS do not BTW).
I have this concealer in the shade Cream. It comes in a tube with a doefoot applicator.
I don't really have dark circles, but do like to have decent coverage under my eyes to help give me that well-rested look. I feel like this concealer delivers exactly what I want. I've been using MAC's Select Moisture Cover Concealer (NW20) and I do still love the MAD for a lighter coverage than the Superstay gives me.
*Super creamy consistency
*Doesn't settle into fine lines
*Blends wonderfully with all of my frequently used foundations and TM's (Lancome Tiente Idole Ultra in Bisque 2, LM TM in Nude, EL DW Light in intensity 3, and Maybelline Superstay 24 hour in Nude)
*Cheap cheap cheap
*Hasn't broken me out (yet)
*Not a wide color range
*a little goes a LONG way
*takes a bit longer to set up than MAC
I use this concealer when I want more coverage than my MAC will give me. I'd say I use them both equally. This is a little more difficult to blend than my MAC, but I am in love with the consistency! It's so creamy and sets up so well! It doesn't budge at all especially when I set it with a powder.
Age: 25-29 Skin: Combination, Medium, Warm Hair: Red, Wavy, Medium Eyes: Hazel
I bought this along with the foundation in a set on clearance at Target awhile ago, and it was the last one so I got it despite the fact that it was one shade to light. So I don't use this as a concealer, I use it as a eyeshadow primer and it works well. I want to get it in the right shade so I can try it as a concealer, but for now this will do, it is lighter than my skin tone, so it works well for my lids and it evens out any darkness I any have on them. It keeps my shadow in place longer, and doesn't interfere with the color of my shadows. So far I like this, and can't wait to try it as a concealer....
Age: 36-43 Skin: Combination, Fair, Cool Hair: Blond, Straight, Medium Eyes: Blue
I love this concealer!!! I have tried so many brands from drugstore to high end and this is the only one that does what is supposed to do. It covers really well, blends easily and stays put for hours! I am slightly oily in the t-zone and this area is usually where I have a need for concealer. I put it on any blemish or red spot early in the morning and it lasts me straight through to the evening. The consistency is not too thick or too thin. It's just creamy enough without being greasy feeling and although I am sensitive to a lot of ingredients this has not caused breakouts. It says 24HR on the tube and I don't know if it would last that long but I am extremely impressed with this concealer. I don't have any under eye issues so I have not tried it there. I wear NC20 in MAC and chose the ivory shade for this concealer. It's a bit light, but once it's blended and I apply loose powder and blush it's undetectable. This is definitely HG for me and because drugstore companies pull their products so quickly, I am definitely stocking up in case this is discontinued.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Combination, Olive Hair: Brunette Eyes: Brown
24 hours? How about two?! This product definitely didn't live up to its claims of long-lasting concealer on my skin. It faded quickly, even when worn over foundation AND under powder, and it caked up under my nose, even though I don't overapply. I guess the search continues to find a lasting concealer...
Age: 25-29 Skin: Combination, Fair-Medium Hair: Brown Eyes: Hazel
This is a great concealer at a great price. I have recently gotten sick of paying a ton of money on cosmetics, so I've been on the hunt to find drug store brands that are comparable to my department store staples. I have been a devoted fan of Origin's Quick Hide! concealer, up until I discovered this little Maybelline gem. Superstay works just as good as my old Origins concealer, at less than half the cost.
Superstay does not crack or settle into lines at all. Where ever you put it is where it will stay until you wash it off. The bottle says that it has 24 hour staying power, and I believe it! Works great for hiding both blemishes and dark under-eye circles. Looks totally natural and flawless. Definitely glad I gave this one a try.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Dry, Olive Hair: Brunette Eyes: Green
I LOVE THIS CONCEALER!!! i think i found my hg... i have dark circles, some days are worse than others! i usually have to put on a lot of concealer to hide my dark circles, then i have to reapply it throughout the day.. then whenever i put to much on it cakes, and it looks bad! with this i barely have to put any on, i just put a dab on each side and rub it in ( you have to rub it in quickly because it dries really fast) and it looks amazing!! it last all day and it doesnt cake at all!!! i dont think this is drying to my under eye area, but i always put eye cream on before i use anything! now it barely takes me any time to put on my concealer which before it did.. i LOVE THIS STUFF!!!
Age: 19-24 Skin: Dry, Medium Hair: Brown, Coarse Eyes: Brown
love this concealer!! its the only concealer that does stay on without caking. a lil goes a long way, so i would recommend using a thin layer. i have very severe dark circles, and this covers them up very well. i actually prefer this over MAC studio finish concealer for my dark circles. i think i found my perfect concealer.
Age: 36-43 Skin: Sensitive, Fair Hair: Brunette Eyes: Blue
Well, the only good thing I can say about this product is that it is very pigmented and gives a lot of coverage. That being said, I hated it and it went back to Rite Aid today for a full refund. With this product a little goes a VERY long way. I found it cakey and it emphasized my fine lines around my eyes. Also, it is not blendable at all. Dries way too quick. The lightest shade was almost white. Definitely would not recommend.
Age: 18 & Under Skin: Combination, Fair-Medium, Warm Hair: Black, Wavy, Medium Eyes: Brown
I've been using this daily (in medium beige) for about two months now, and it's a good product, but not HG worthy, in my opinion.
It's a matte formula, and it stays for about 9 hours on my (fairly clear) skin. I think it's actually very drying, so I've stopped using it under my eyes and have been using it on my forehead and around my nose, which is a shame since it did wonders to my horrible dark circles. I would say that if there is enough of this concealer on your skin, it will stay wet enough for you to apply quickly, but if you only need a small dab or let it sit on your skin, then it's pretty hard to work with. I used it alone for a few weeks, and it covered my imperfections but blended in well enough that it looked like I had nothing on my face at all, that was definitely something that will make me buy this again.
About the packaging: Around a month ago, the cap on the concealer started cracking, and now there's a big crack all the way through, and I can see the end of the wand. This concealer has never left my makeup stash at home, and has never been dropped or thrown, so I was a little disappointed in the quality of the packaging. I did contact customer service, and they were pretty fast about refunding me for the concealer.
Age: 30-35 Skin: Other Hair: Other Eyes: Blue
I really like this concealer! Granted, I don't have a lot of experience with concealers, but I picked this up (in medium beige) to help with some redness and broken capillaries around my nose. The texture is quite nice--matte--with good coverage. I wouldn't use it under my eyes, though, definitely too matte/dry. The color selection is slim and a *bit* off for me, but if applied with a light hand it doesn't matter much. The staying power is, indeed, 'super.' I dabbed this on and went out cross country skiing and it didn't budge. Yay!
Age: 30-35 Skin: Combination, Medium Hair: Brunette Eyes: Hazel
I also found that the light was too light\ and white toned, while the medium beige was too dark and brownish. Perhaps mixing the two will work, or using this product in conjuction with another might do the trick. As far as the coverage and the finish, both seem great (natural appearance but full coverage). As for those who've said that the product is too fast drying and difficult to apply, simply use the wand to place three dots of product under one eye at a time and pat and blend with a fingertip. I had no trouble applying it.
NOTE: The product seemed slightly harsh for under my eyes, as there was apparently some sensitivity to the ingredients in it.
Age: Unknown Skin: Combination, Fair, Neutral Hair: Other, Wavy, Medium Eyes: Other
A good concealer if you can get a color match. I'm usually easy to match, but the lightest shade was a bit too light/white-toned for me, and the second shade looked too dark. I like to apply concealer with my own brush instead of the wand supplied, and it was very hard to clean this out of the brush, so it was a bit more tenacious than I'd like. Staying power, blendability, and finish are all good, and it is buildable up to full coverage.