|Would buy this product again.||61%|
Age: 19-24 Skin: Dry, Fair, Warm Hair: Brunette, Wavy Eyes: Hazel
This stuff is absolute garbage, IMO. I needed a new liquid eyeliner, so decided to try this one as it was on sale.
-This stuff is extremely black and very dark. No need to build it up. One line and it's black as black can be.
-I love the brush. Small and thin applicator makes lining your eyes so simple. Very easy to make a thin line, like I prefer.
-This stuff doesn't last at all. It's 90% gone within like 3 hours and 100% gone by 5. And I have long days. So I need my makeup (including liner) to stay on for 12 hour days. This doesn't come close at all.
-This takes soooo long to dry. I line my eyes, and then I have to keep my eyes closed for like 7 minutes after I apply it (cause I have slightly hooded eyes, and if I open my eyes my eyeliner completely smudges. It's so frustrating cause I can't really do anything for those 7 or so minutes cause then the eyeliner smudges all over my eyeshadow. Just such a nuisance.
The cons outweigh the pros for me. I gave it 2 stars for the nice packaging and applicator, and the very dark black colour. But the fact that it just doesn't last and smudges and takes so long to dry, definite no's for me. Won't repurchase.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Combination, Tan Hair: Black Eyes: Black
This is my first liquid eyeliner. I would not repurchase because this liquid eyeliner is just too hard to use.
Product: The pigmentation is good and you get a very black line on your lids. However, this eyeliner takes FOREVER to dry on your lids. Thankfully I don't have monolids so I dont have to stand still waiting for it to dry, although I still do for abit just to make sure that it doesn't get everywhere. One reviewer said it takes 30 seconds to dry but I think it takes much longer than that. I stood in front of a fan with my eyes closed for a few minutes and it still hadn't dried totally.
Application:The application tip of the brush is very long so I find it really hard to control. I ended up without a very jagged line and had to go over it with my pencil to even out the jags. The tip is very fine so I can see why people like it. But if you have shaky hands like me, make sure your pencil eyeliner is on standby to clean up the jagged lines.
Staying power: Staying power is good because I used my HG eye primer (etude house proof 10, really the best out there) under it. I don't know how the staying power will be without it!
I might try this again if I can't find a liquid eyeliner that is easier to use but I wouldn't recommend this eyeliner to liquid newbies like me! I will update again if my skills get better with this and I find it easier to use.
UPDATE: my skills with liquid eyeliner are better now so the liner is starting to look better and better. i really like how dark the black is but its really frustrating how long it takes to dry.
for the girls complaining about smudging out there: there's no way any make up is going to stay on your eyes if your lids get oily (which they will) so I recommend purchasing a very good eye primer so your eye make up stays in place all day. i use etude house proof 10 eye primer and i've never had to worry about my eye make up smudging since then. highly recommend!
Age: 30-35 Skin: Sensitive, Medium, Warm Hair: Brunette, Straight, Fine Eyes: Green
Love love love. Please do not ever DC. The finest brush tip, thin but not watery formula, and black, not harsh black, but soft black. Not waterproof but not vulgar gloomy vinyl thick, so absolutely perfect. Would repurchase a thousand times over.
Age: 18 & Under Skin: Combination, Fair-Medium Hair: Brown Eyes: Black
The tip is very thin, it's quite easy to draw a cat eye. It is not waterproof whatsoever, but I guess that means it's easy to remove.
Age: 25-29 Skin: Oily, Fair Hair: Brunette Eyes: Blue
This flakes off after a few hours, ruining the line you spent ages trying to get straight with the 'just ok' built-in brush. The product is a good price but it's a waste of money if it doesn't last for me. Having a dried out Mac Blacktrack I'm now going to try Clinique cream liner.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Acne-prone, Fair Hair: Brown, Wavy, Medium Eyes: Blue
I have been using this product since I was 15 and I am now 23, need I say more?
Sometimes I'm led to believe the grass is greener on the other side and I try a different eyeliner from Rimmel or another brand...but none of them are as great as this one!
+ versatile: you can choose the shape and thickness of the line
+ durable: I have oily skin, attended sweaty rock concert and spent a summer in humid Asia, and it always stays on.
+ pigment: black in one go (sometimes two)
+ easy application once you get the hang of it: I find this is even easier to apply than pencil liners
- maximum duration with one bottle, using it almost every day, is one year. By that time it will dry out and the brush will not be so pointy as it once was.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Combination, Fair-Medium Hair: Black Eyes: Brown
I'm not a big liquid liner user. I don't usually line my upper lash line as I tightline it with pencil. So since it was on sale, I thought "hey why not?" Maybe this review is biased as I have monolids (no crease).
Good: good color, thin lines
Bad: doesn't dry fast enough (as soon as I open my eye a bit, it imprinted on my lid), brush is flimsy (I don't feel I have much control)
So I guess it's not great for monolids.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Dry, Fair Hair: Blond Eyes: Blue
I really love this eyeliner. It stays on and I love the color of it. It stays put during the time you wear it and comes off pretty easily. It takes a seconds to dry, but other than that, I absolutely adore it.
Age: 18 & Under Skin: Dry, Fair Hair: Black Eyes: Brown
First of all, for $5, you get such a small amount of product. The tube is so small. I kind of feel like i'm being ripped off. Cause I had another liquid eyeliner by NYC that was $3 and such a bigger tube. This eyeliner fails to create an easy arch. I have to draw on an arch on the corner THHHHEEEEEN fill in and draw the rest on my eye. So I don't end up wasting too much of the product when I mess up and have to redraw/refill it in. So i just draw the outline of an arch then fill it in with this eyeliner or a different one. I'm so picky, afraid that i'll run out of liquid eyeliner. Also when done applying this eyeliner, it's best to fan yourself for like 30 seconds because it takes a long time to dry BUTTTTT! It doesn't budge throughout the day. Thank the lord! But then again, it's not waterproof. The packaging is decent but not enough PAZAM to catch my eye to the point where it can't be ignored. I just know that I bought this cause it was cheap and liquid eyeliner.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Combination, Olive Hair: Brunette Eyes: Brown
I can't even remember the number of times I've repurchased this eyeliner, I first bought it five years ago when I was first starting to experiment with makeup and I've repurchased it time and time again since then. This eyeliner is my HG liner, I can't imagine my makeup bag without it and I haven't used another liquid liner since. I bought it in Black Glamour and it's the perfect dark matte black for a dramatic cat eye flick or simply to line your water line with. The colour is really impressive and if you're looking for a black liner (none of this dark grey stuff please makeup companies) then I would seriously consider buying this. The formula is great although it can take a while to dry but once it does it doesn't budge at all but it's still so easy to remove at the end of the day!
The brush is right up my street, it's REALLY fine so if you're not comfortable with liquid liner then I would consider practicing a lot first or trying another liner with a thicker nib. It can be quite tricky to get the hang of it but I love this brush, it's perfect for me as I like the option of creating a really thin line or a bold one.
The packaging is great, you don't get too much product in it especially if you're planning on wearing this every day but considering how I can pick this up from Boots for around £5-6 it's totally worth it.
I wouldn't consider buying any other liner and I really hope Rimmel never discontinue this! It's my makeup staple and I couldn't imagine creating a 40s flick with anything else.