|Would buy this product again.||79%|
Age: 18 & Under Skin: Very Oily, Fair-Medium Hair: Brown, Wavy, Medium Eyes: Brown
I got this eyeliner in black, and it's well pigmented. It shows up on my upper and lower waterline. I have oily lids, so when I apply this on my lid without a primer, I find that after a while the liner starts to transfer to the crease of my lid, which I hate. Overall, good liner.
Age: 25-29 Skin: Sensitive, Fair, Neutral Hair: Brunette, Medium Eyes: Brown
Thought this was my HG liner because it is SOOOOO black, which I love. I think it probably works better in the waterline, but outside of the waterline (like I usually use it), it smudges horribly! Also, I think there's something slightly irritating/allergic about this, because my eyes do seem a tad irritated when I wear it. I just think there might better things out there, and am looking to try L'Oreal or Stila some time soon.
Age: 30-35 Skin: Combination, Fair, Neutral Hair: Blond, Straight, Fine Eyes: Green
Like some other reviewers, I struggled to get much definition with this. Presumably because of its waterproof formulation, it's not ideal for the waterline (which seems to repel the colour.) Used elsewhere I found that the colour (black) was less rich/intense than other liners I've used, though it also smudged less.
I prefer the creamy, smooth, dramatic colour afforded by Prestige's Total Intensity liner for my waterline. Although, the 'back by demand' (at least in the UK) Avon Supershock gel liner is even better - delivering the buttery intensity of pencils like Prestige Total Intensity or Mally Evercolor Starlight etc, but much less smudgy (and cheaper, too!)
Age: 18 & Under Skin: Very Dry, Fair-Medium Hair: Black Eyes: Brown
I bought this after reading the great reviews on here.
First of all, let me just tell you - this IS waterproof. But let's not mistake that for being everything-proof. This liner smudges like there's no tomorrow - I was so excited to use it, and wanted to love it so badly, but after coming home with raccoon eyes I knew I wouldn't ever use it again.
Don't waste your money or time.
Age: 18 & Under Skin: Dry, Medium Hair: Black Eyes: Brown
This lasts a really long time!! Pretty much all day even through the sweat and humidity. However I bought this for waterline. So when i tried this on my waterline, this product completely let me down. The black did not show up at all whatsoever!! I had to color back and forth on my waterline with so much pressure and intensity just to make it show up a little bit. So yes, if I only lined my lower lashline I would totally buy this again. (:
Age: 36-43 Skin: Combination, Fair-Medium Hair: Brunette, Fine Eyes: Brown
A reasonable eyeliner for the price. I had this in Trance, a denim blue, and it's the first eyeliner I've used up in years. I don't have smudge problems because I use this as an eyeliner then set it with a coating of dark shadow--sort of a smoky-eye express. It does fade a little as the day wears on, though, so a refresh would be necessary before going out after work. For the price, it's fine. If you want permanent, heavy duty stuff, this probably isn't it.
Age: 30-35 Skin: Combination, Fair-Medium Hair: Red, Curly Eyes: Blue
This is my new go-to for lining my waterline. It goes on smoothly with no pulling and LASTS.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Combination, Fair-Medium Hair: Brunette, Straight, Medium Eyes: Brown
I use this on my waterline everyday, but it fades in about 2 hours. The only reason I keep using it is because it doesn't smudge. Other eyeliners, when put on the waterline, will smudge down onto your cheeks. This one doesn't do that which is good, but it should last longer considering it's waterproof. It's cheap though, and until I can find a good alternative I'll continue using this.
Age: 25-29 Skin: Acne-prone, Fair-Medium, Neutral Hair: Blond, Straight, Fine Eyes: Brown
Waterproof my a$$. This didn't last at all. It was a semi warm and windy day minimal watering, I didn't touch my eyes and I didn't go swimming.
I applied this at 11:00 this morning and expected it to last til well into the night. I applied this on my upper lash line, lower lash line and the waterline. The waterline disappeared about an hour later. And slowly throughout the day the rest started smearing off.
Then hours later after shopping and margaritas I passed out and took a nap. I woke up looking like somebody punched me in the eyes. That was the last straw, I should have known this didn't work because it started smudging gradually throughout the day. I seriously fell for all the great reviews. I am glad I only bought one pencil to try out. Hopefully aqua eyes and urban decay will do way better because I'm hitting those up next.
Age: 30-35 Skin: Dry, Fair Hair: Black Eyes: Brown
This to my surprise, it lies among the top of all the waterproof liners I have tried. It stays on very well throughout the whole day and doesn't smudge at all. It does dry a bit sitting in my drawer so it's a bit harder to glide on my eyeline after a while. But when I sharpen it to remove the product that dried, it works just as well as before. It's a bit harder to remove compared to others but to me it's ok...and it's sooo cheap!! I have one in every bags I carry. :p