MAC • Eyeshadow in Mystery • Eye Shadow
|Would buy this product again.||85%|
Age: 19-24 Skin: Sensitive, Fair Hair: Brunette Eyes: Blue
Such a good multipurpose shadow. I use this for my brows, and in the outer crease, of for a great smokey eye! Really matte and pretty! The MAC eye shadows are also such good prices considering the quality.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Combination, Fair Hair: Brunette, Wavy, Fine Eyes: Brown
I use it for almost everything: lining, smokey look, on the crease, and more rarely for filling my brows (only because it fits better on dark brows- mine are lighter). Great on top of eyeliner/pencil, either to set it and keep it from smudging, or to make the line look softer and more refined. Its matte, cool, not extremely dark colour makes it a basic product in my vanity case. Its greyish shade flatters brown eyes. When I travel, I take this and an eyebrush, and I don't even need any eyeliner with me. Also, the texture/quality is very good, and it stays well and long on oily lids, but I would say this about all MAC eyeshadows that I've tried. Very convenient for me.
Age: 30-35 Skin: Other, Fair, Cool Hair: Brunette Eyes: Other
I'm kicking myself for not getting this sooner! I've been using Espresso as a brow filler for, oh, over 10 years now, and while it did the job fine, sometimes I felt it pulled too warm on my fair skin and very dark brows - almost unnaturally reddish in certain lighting or photos. And I never was able to use it as an eyeshadow since it's too warm (just like saddle and soft brown, which look horrid on me). Mystery is the dark hair/cool skin answer to Espresso - it's a perfect, dark, muted brown with absolutely zero warmth. It looks natural on my brows and also pairs well in the crease or outer corner with all of my beloved taupe shadows. Pigmentation and blendability are great. HG!
Age: 19-24 Skin: Sensitive, Fair, Cool Hair: Brunette, Straight, Medium Eyes: Blue
To start off, I have very pale skin with freckles, and dark hair and blue eyes. This color unlike any other brows I've come across, a sort of a mauvy cool-toned brown without any red in it - which I love.
I use this through my eyebrows every day and it's perfect for that and lasts really well. For most looks I put this in the crease to darken it, but I recently found a new way to use it and it has become my go-to make up look: Apply mystery with a regular application brush, preferably a bit softer than usual brushes, and apply it all along my top lashline as well as 2/3 on the lower lashline. Then I smudge this a bit to soften it, apply black eyeliner to my top waterline and finish off with mascara. Voila, an appropriate, super easy smokey eye suitable for daytime and with some more eyeliner for evening. Works great.
I think it might be a bit too ashy on people with warm undertones, but it is worth a shot. It's a perfect cool-toned dark brown, highly pigmented and super smooth to apply. However, I think MAC eyeshadows are a bit too expensive, luckily they last forever. The packaging is hideous and I really hope that MAC do something with that. But great color though :-)
Age: 19-24 Skin: Acne-prone Hair: Brunette Eyes: Blue
BEAUTIFUL color! I think this may be a HG cool brown e/s. I was looking for a cool, brown, and neutral shadow that wouldn't be so light that it didn't show up nor something too too dark that I would be embarrassed to wear this during the day. It is on the darker end of the spectrum but w/o being harsh. It is a satin finish so it isn't shimmery or sparkly but sort of like a soft matte shade. All in all....love it.
Age: 30-35 Skin: Acne-prone, Fair-Medium, Warm Hair: Black, Straight, Fine Eyes: Other
Mystery and Ricepaper are the ONLY MAC shadows that I will purchase over and over for as long as I live. Rather dramatic statement to make, yes, but they're such staples in my gigantic makeup collection, it's hard to imagine doing a makeup look without them! Mystery is my go to color for my brows. I'm Asian NC35 and it fills my sparse brows in perfectly. I use my Laura Mercier double ended brow brush and I get perfect brows every time. Ricepaper is THE tear duct color I use for almost every look. Love!
Age: 18 & Under Skin: Normal, Fair-Medium Hair: Brunette Eyes: Brown
One of the best MAC eyeshadows. I absolutely love this eyeshadow. I use it everyday to fill in my brows, and I also use it in the outer corner of my eye to intensify any nuetral eyeshadow look. Mystery is a cool toned medium to dark brown and looks really nice on cool toned skins. If your warmer toned handwritten is a good reddish based medium dark brown that is also nice.
Age: 18 & Under Skin: Dry, Fair-Medium Hair: Blond Eyes: Brown
Mystery is one of my all time favorite mac eyeshadows. It's a dark cool toned brown that is perfect for the outer corner and adding smokiness to any look. I also really like this for my eyebrows, because it's cool tone it looks really natural and doesn't clash with my ashy dark brown hair like a lot of reddish eyeshadows do. However I have to say that I'd your more of a warmer complexion or you have more golden tones in your hair you might want to try handwritten eyeshadow. It is also a dark brown but is more red based and complements warmer skintones better that mystery will.
Age: 25-29 Skin: Very Oily, Fair-Medium, Warm Hair: Brown, Straight, Medium Eyes: Blue
Can I please give this eyeshadow 10 lipsticks?! I LOVE THIS!
For some reason, when I buy dark brown MAC eyeshadows I go for the ones with red tones. While they look great on my skintone I was looking for something that was just a plain brown - this eyeshadow was exactly what I was looking for. The website says its "plum brown" but goes on mostly brown. I love wearing this in my crease and outer V with something like Blanc Type or Brule on my lid. It also looks great in the crease with Satin Taupe, or in the crease with "Charcoal Brown" on my lid. Amazing on the lid with something like "Carbon" in the crease/outer V for a smoky brown eye.
Like most MAC eyeshadows it goes on nicely, lasts all day with an eye primer and blends VERY nicely. If you like neutrals like me this is a definite must for your eyeshadow collection. I will definitely repurchase when I run out. One of my favorite MAC eyeshadows for sure! Extremely versatile and a must have for me!
Age: 19-24 Skin: Dry, Fair, Neutral Hair: Brown, Medium Eyes: Blue
Hell YES! The most perfect brown shadow ever. This one is my go to shade and I seriously love it.
I've often got problems finding browns that suits my natural coloring, my fair skin and dark brown hair are both very ashy. When I got this the MAC employee I talked to said "Should you really get a shade THIS ashy for your brows..?" to me, and I was like "HAHA yeah I guess..?"
So as I said, I mostly use it for my brows and in my lashline for everyday make up. If I'm doing smokey brown eye looks I prefer this one or Handwritten. Go MAC, your neutral shadows might be the star of the whole brand.