|Would buy this product again.||50%|
Age: 36-43 Skin: Normal, Fair, Warm Hair: Other Eyes: Blue
I don't understand how anyone can use this product. I used it to line my waterline and yes, it is super soft and very black. Not like any other liner. But then, within about 10 minutes, IT MELTS EVERYWHERE. It gets all under my eyes and messes up my makeup. And I don't mean some smudging, like many eyeliners do, I mean dark black eyeliner all over my eye area. It's horrible. I'm not sure what others are doing to make this work.
Age: 30-35 Skin: Combination, Tan, Warm Hair: Black, Wavy, Fine Eyes: Brown
So I am on the fence with this one..I am Indian and use alot of black/brown smudge cake/kajal type liners on my eyes and love the way they look..
This pencil is great in that it's as dark as a liquid (it's black black) and smudgy (that's how I wear it)...but it's just so messy. Everytime you handle it you have to be so careful you don't get any anywhere or you have a mess on your hand...
I used this only on my upper lash line - I draw a line and smudge. I placed a few dots and use a smudge brush. I use LM cake line to tightline and that doesn't budge ...I have used these a few times for that purpose too but I wouldn't trust it to look like it looks like I apply an hour later. As I have gotten older I don't wear dark colors in my waterline/lower lash line anymore..as it looks too harsh.
I found this much easier to smudge than 24/7 Zero and MAC's engraved - both of which left a small space b/t my upper lashes and the liner, and tugged my eye area. I was never a fan of MAC's smolder...
You have to sharpen often and it does waste product...
Bottom line - I think these were great when they came out (there was nothing like it) But now there is UD perversion, the Milani liquify pencils...and those probably do a similar job with less mess (I have never used either - but in swatches they are both soft and jet black)
Age: 19-24 Skin: Normal, Fair-Medium Hair: Brunette Eyes: Brown
This eyeliner is very comparable to Urban Decay's 24/7 eyeliner. Urban Decay gives you more pencil for your money, but both Urban Decay's eyeliner & Stila cost the same price. I bought this eyeliner from hearing so many great reviews on it. I liked it, it wasn't the worst eyeliner I've ever used, but it definitely wasn't the best either. This eyeliner doesn't last long without smudging, (especially on the waterline), which is why I would not buy this eyeliner again. I'm still on the hunt for the best eyeliner for my waterline that stays put for a decent amount of time, without smudging. This eyeliner is steeply priced as well, & I don't believe the price for this product matches the quality. I'm willing to pay a good amount of money for anything, if it works & delivers up to its expectations. I've never been cheap for good quality products, I'm a true believer in what you get, is what you pay for. However, for this eyeliner, that's not the case. Urban Decay's 24/7 eyeliner works better than this one, in my opinion. So, if it's between Stila & Urban Decay, I would go with Urban Decay. Although Urban Decay's doesn't last that long on my waterline either, it's still better quality than Stila's. Urban Decay's also gives more intense color. Overall, this wasn't that bad of an eyeliner, but I would not buy this again.
Age: 30-35 Skin: Acne-prone, Fair-Medium, Neutral Hair: Black, Wavy, Coarse Eyes: Hazel
I absolutely love this. I use it to create my smokey eye and it always looks great, however, I never use it on my top lash line. I always use it on bottom lashline and bottom inner. Lasts a long time and love that it's so nice and creamy not dry. It is also very pigmented which I totally love. I own it in onyx but plan to buy all colors.
Age: 25-29 Skin: Combination, Medium Hair: Black Eyes: Brown
This eye pencil is extremely creammy and pigmented. yes if put onthe water line and lower lash line it smears/travels BUT it's great for the upper lashline and smudging for a smokey softer look. This is how I use it instead of as an eyeliner for my waterline...
Age: 36-43 Skin: Combination, Fair-Medium Hair: Black, Straight, Fine Eyes: Brown
This is probably the worst eyeliner pencil (smears like crazy after being on the eye for 10 minutes) I have found in my 31 years of wearing eyeliner. The SA at Saks wanted to try this on me and granted she did a good job giving me a sexy, smoky, sultry look at the counter so I bought this in the onyx and indigo color. However after walking around Saks and glancing into a mirror, I was shocked that this had already smeared, BADLY. I immediately went to the ladies' room and wiped off most of this inferior product.
At home, I wanted to give this a chance but trying to sharpen this pencil is frustrating as you can easily sharpen off 20% of the entire pencil trying to get a decent tip! Cute packaging yes (I like Stila eye products in general, ironically their eye shadows have great staying power) but this is a horrible product period.
If you like eye pencils or liners that actually stay ON the eye, these are my favorites (I have used eyeliner since I was 14 years old):
- Tarina Tarantino - Eye Dream Hyperliner (beautiful colors and the BEST long wearing, non-smudging color ever). Easy to achieve a "smokey" look that actually stays on & doesn't veer off & make you look like a mental patient!
- Urban Decay - was my tops until I tried the Tarantino pencil.
- Sephora's Waterproof Eyeliner - 3rd place compared to Tarantino
- Make Up Forever's Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil: pretty good but less rich color and doesn't last as long and smudges more than Tarantino and Urban Decay.
- Maybelline Eyebrow Pencil (but requires a lighter or matches). When I was a teen and sometimes even now, I'd light the tip of the Maybelline brow pencil with a lighter to "lightly" melt the eyeliner, and then when it was ALMOST hard/cool, I'd draw on my upper line and it would "cool" and set perfectly and not budge (this technique does require some skill and a makeup artist taught me this).
- I have tried EVERY pencil out there (Almay, C. Dior, Chanel, E. Arden, Maybelline, Revlon, Stila etc.). None of these compare to Tarantino and Urban Decay.
- Bobbi Brown's Long Wear Gel Eyeliner: this is the longest lasting liner in a pot/cake eyeliner (more smudge proof and doesn't dry out like Stila's Smudge Pot). BB's deep blue "Cobalt Ink" is a GORGEOUS however Tarantino's "Cute Robot" (Deep Blue/Violet is even MORE gorgeous). Fun and glamorous to use, but I find this smudges more than the UD 24/7 Pencil or Tarantino Eye Pencil.
- Liquid liners (whether brush or pen style) simply do not work for me as when my eyes water, I have a horrible huge black smudge on my eye which unless I'm lucky enough to have a friend inform me, I have no idea I'm walking around with a partial black eye (like the Stila Kajal Eye Pencil!).
Age: 19-24 Skin: Other, Fair Hair: Black, Wavy, Coarse Eyes: Blue
I honestly love this product for a smokey effect. It's funny that a lot of people complain that it smudges because it's designed to blend and be smudged. I usually wear this under liquid liner (urban decay) and love the effect. I also have it in tigers eye and it brings out blue eyes very well. It's great alone or for a dramatic look so I definitely love it!
Age: 19-24 Skin: Combination, Medium, Warm Hair: Black, Straight, Fine Eyes: Brown
Best eyeliner I've ever used! This applies so well and stays on all day.
It's incredibly creamy and pigmented and is the best eyeliner I've ever used on my water line. It is a bit pricey, so I only use it when I'm going somewhere special, or going to be out for a long time.
The only thing I don't like is that it requires sharpening. It applies best when it has a fine point, and in order to keep it sharp, you have to sharpen it frequently. This causes you to lose a lot of the product and go through it quickly.
This product could benefit from being an 'automatic' liner (the kind that you twist and the product comes out the top).
Age: 25-29 Skin: Dry, Medium Hair: Black, Straight, Medium Eyes: Brown
This product retails for $18.00 USD. But I purchased this in a set from Costco for $12, so check your Costco if they still carry it. This is a standard black eyeliner pencil which you have to sharpen. It sharpens easily with my inexpensive and expensive sharpeners. I find the black color quite pigmented. The great thing about this eyeliner is that it glides onto your eyes very easily! I didnít have to tug on my eyelid nor applied extra pressure to my waterline. The eyeliner smears everywhere. So, if you have hooded eyes, this eyeliner is a pain. So prepare to have panda eyes! In case you were wondering, I tried this with eye shadow primer as well and ended up with the same results. However, I donít want to throw this product out, so this product is great for creating a smoky eye look since it does blend very easily with a brush! So as a caveat, if you have oily or hooded lids, this will probably smear all over the place.
Age: 18 & Under Skin: Combination, Tan, Warm Hair: Other, Medium Eyes: Brown
You REALLY need primer under this. You should always use primer. I use primer with everything. This is a dark, inky black that glides on and is easy to smudge/blur the line. This also makes it very forgiving, you can smudge off mistakes before it sets in. Doesn't pull or tug at my lids at all. Also, it's a soft pencil but doesn't get mushy and break off inside a sharpener.
Whether or not you will like this depends on want you want from it. If you are new to eyeliner and want black on your upper lids, this is good, because as I said, it's very forgiving and you can smudge any mistakes off with a cotton swab. On the top lid it will last if you use a primer.
If you want to blacken your waterline, this will show up VERY black, but you need to re-apply it every 2 or so hours because it fades.
If you like to line your lower lash line/lid, this is probably not the pencil for you. It tends to fade and may even run a little if your eyes water. Even with primer. The fading on the lower lash line is why I gave it 3 lippies. It's just not for what I'm looking for in a liner.