Physicians Formula • Organic Wear Fake Out Mascara • Mascara
|Would buy this product again.||27%|
Age: 25-29 Skin: Oily, Fair-Medium, Neutral Hair: Black, Straight, Medium Eyes: Hazel
meh..Idk what to say about this mascara..it kind of disappointed me.. I liked their organic wear super jumbo lash way better than this formula...it made my lashes extend thicken and defined them much nicer than this one..funny thing is it dried out really fast for me and believe me i know the rules of mascara preservation but this tube just dried out quick which in turn left my applications drier and with dry crusty clumps under my eyes at the end of the day..also when being washed off at the end of the day it kinda burned..If i ever want to go back to a good organic mascara i think I'll just go back to super jumbo lash or my bare escentuals flawless definition mascara. I'm a fan of physician's formula cosmetics...just not a fan of this particular product
Age: 19-24 Skin: Combination, Fair, Neutral Hair: Brunette, Curly, Coarse Eyes: Brown
the worst. never dried and felt gumny on lashes. just clumped everything together in a sticky glob. very dry goopy formula felt old even though it was fresh. threw it out. wanted to luv it..bummer. cute packaging though.
Age: 25-29 Skin: Combination, Fair, Neutral Hair: Brown, Curly, Medium Eyes: Hazel
I buy a lot of PF products, but this one is just terrible. The brush is good, but there's hardly any mascara on it. I have to put 100 coats on just to notice a difference. The tube is too bulky and awkward. I use this as a de-clumpifier if my other mascara clumps a bit. The one pro is that it is smudge-free and easy to take off.
Age: 25-29 Skin: Combination, Medium, Neutral Hair: Brown, Straight, Medium Eyes: Green
I was so bummed that this stuff sucked lol. You can pretty much stop reading after that statement! But if you need the gorey details and perhaps a laugh or two, then read on. Basically I went on a health kick after going on the EWG site and was horrified at some of the chemicals being put on our faces everyday, I wanted a clean sweep! So I figure mascara is kind of a good place to start considering it goes on my eyes and all. I see that this mascara was rated as having like no bad stuff in it (just because something says organic on the label doesn't mean they are telling the truth, read the label and research first!) Anyway, this stuff made my eyes BURRRRRRN like I mean was commuting to work and barely made it home alive burning, like almost had to pull over burning! I think Physicians Formula gets a little over zealous with the herbs and stuff in it! (and there are many products I like from them so no diss intended) But anyway, I also hated the brush, the product was thick and clumpy. I actually even tried exchanging this pink one for the green one and still sucked lol. Kudos for the for trying to make a healthy mascara, but need a better formula and brush. The packaging design so incredibly nice though! But yeah, not gonna lie it's expensive and kinda awful lol if a make up can kill you :l I wanna say though that my mom had contacted this company regarding something that happened (can't remember) and they SERIOUSLY took care of it, super nice and caring company.
Age: 30-35 Skin: Combination, Fair-Medium Hair: Brown Eyes: Brown
Made my eyes burn and water...smeared so easy...loved the brush but it just didn't work for me :/
Age: 25-29 Skin: Other, Fair Hair: Blond Eyes: Hazel
I have tried a lot of Physician's Formula Organic Wear products including their other mascaras. I like that this product is free of chemicals and a decent price for an organic drug store mascara. These two qualities have caused me to continually return to this makeup line. Overall I'm not super impressed by the mascara but it does the job for everyday wear that doesn't irritate the skin around the eyes. Keep in mind that if you are comparing this mascara with other mascaras in this line there isn't much difference in the mascara its self, there are differences in the brushes. So research the type of brush that you should use for your desired effect (this is true for any mascara, the bang is in your brush).
Pros: I like the packaging but its a little difficult to get used to the shape of the wand handle while applying the product. It has pretty good lasting power and isn't flaky. My lashes generally separate while applying the product which I like a lot.
Cons: The mascara is a bit gunky and the opening of the tube does not taper to scrape off excess product so like most mascaras you need to either wipe it off with a tissue or wiggle the brush as its pulled out. The formula tends to dry quickly while applying and I go through a tube quicker than I would another mascara. There is a big difference in this mascara after my first few weeks of using the product (works very well, glides on easily) than after it's had moderate use. That may be a downfall of organic mascara in general. The brush is huge so application takes a steady hand and an adjustment period so that you don't spread the mascara on the skin around the eyes, especially on lower lashes. If you love or need and organic product I suggest placing an index or business card beneath the lower lash line and/or behind the upper lash line to act as a shield while applying.
I like this product over some of Organic Wear's other mascaras. It gives a little more length but I find that their products are more voluminous rather than lengthening due to the brush size. I hope to find a mascara with more than one wand to use soon, or I may purchase a variety of wands to use with this mascara. This product is free of harmful chemicals but it does contain citrus as one of the main ingredients. If you tend to rub your eyes while crying I do not suggest this product because it will sting. The only time I've had an issue with stinging while removing is when I forgot to take my eye makeup off with coconut oil (which I highly suggest) before washing my face.
I've bought this product several times but I will be trying a non-organic drug store brand to see which one helps the dryness I've been experiencing with my eyes over the last year as well as lengthen a little better than this one.
Age: 30-35 Skin: Acne-prone, Medium Hair: Brown Eyes: Hazel
I read several good reviews of the product and really wanted to love it. the packaging is super cute and the brush seems like it would work well. I have thin, yet longish lashes and need a formula to plump them up. To get a bit of volume you have to apply lots of coats. This results in a spidery mess. This is felt strange on my lashes, a bit heavy. I wore this to a 3D movie and after using the glasses came out with smeared mascara. It runs very easily. Not great for contact lens wearers! I used this several times, but will likely trash it soon.
Age: 25-29 Skin: Combination, Fair-Medium Hair: Brunette Eyes: Brown
I was so excited to try this. It's supposed to be good for your lashes with no parabens or harsh chemicals. Well, I wouldn't even know if that's the case. While the nice fat brush looked so promising, the short stubby bristles couldn't even catch my lashes. When the product was applied it seemed to get everywhere else around my eye but my lashes since I had to get so close and try so hard to grip them. I didn't see any length or any volume, just a mess.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Combination, Dark, Warm Hair: Black, Kinky, Coarse Eyes: Brown
Most mascaras I use are very irritating and sensitive to my eyes. I love how this mascara contains organic ingredients and I love how dark my lashes look after I swipe the brush over them. In order to get that extended lash look, you have to pile on coats and coats of it. I gave it a 3 because it takes awhile for this mascara to dry.
Age: 36-43 Skin: Other Hair: Other Eyes: Other
OMG I love this stuff! I was buying lash injection. this is less than half the price and gives me mega lashes and doesn't smudge or flake all day. Came off easy with Alboline. I'm so glad I tried this after a friend talked me into it! Hope they never stop making it!