Butter London • The Black Knight • Polishes
|Would buy this product again.||50%|
Age: 30-35 Skin: Combination, Fair-Medium, Cool Hair: Red, Straight, Medium Eyes: Green
Alright...Butter London....listen up. I've been avoiding writing this review but, the time has come. I just can't take it anymore. I have purchased only 3 Butter polishes and 1 Lippy and I am dead serious when I say that I will not be repurchasing anything from this brand ever...again.
I love this color, I do. I love most of their colors tbh. The packaging really shows the colors off, makes them look almost good enough to eat. You see them...you want to buy them ALL.
However....the quality SUCKS. Hard.
Every single time I attempt to wear one of my Butter polishes (I have Disco Biscuit, the Black Knight, and No More Waitie Katie) I regret it quickly after. Their formula applies worse than 99 cent store polish. You seriously have to use coats upon coats to get close to the color it looks like in the bottle. Make sure you use a base coat because if you don't and you apply one that has any glitter in it, you're gonna have a bad time, I can promise you that.
What's WEIRD about that is that removing it with polish remover is about the most difficult task I have ever encountered, yet their polish doesn't just chip off...it PEELS off...in large chunks. You'll find em all over your house, in your hair, in your bed. Im not kidding. Every single color has done this and I've tried them all in every way I possibly can...base coat, no base coat, top coat, no top coat...under or over other polish....doesn't matter. After maybe a day of wear after using so much of the bottle to achieve the color it's "supposed" to be it just...pfft...flakes off...leaving a trail of $14 glitter in its wake.
I have NO clue why these are so popular. Yes, the colors and the sparkles are very pretty, but dude...$14 for a bottle of crap polish is absolute insanity. Don't even get me STARTED on the tiny stiff brush...
Their Lippy (which I bought in Trout Pout) was the most DISGUSTING smelling, feeling, looking thing I've put on my lips. Ever. Planet Beauty wouldn't take it back. I might as well have flushed $17 down the toilet. So nasty, I tossed it.
Butter London is a total rip. I've talked to a lot of people who feel the same way and have similar experiences with their products. I honestly feel they are straight up ripping people off under the guise of cute packaging and fine glitter.
Age: 44-55 Skin: Normal, Fair, Cool Hair: Blond, Straight, Fine Eyes: Blue
This is an absolutely gorgeous polish to wear! The color is rich and the glittery sparkles so fine that it's like stardust on your nails. It took 2 coats to cover evenly and I used Seche Vite top coat to seal it all and give it a nice smooth glassy finish. The downsides, and sadly there were a lot: the polish was thick and gloppy and didn't flow on evenly and had to be worked to get a mostly even layer of polish on. It dried very quickly so I had to work fast. The brush handle/cap was small and hard to hold onto. The brush itself was small too and had stray bristles that kept a perfect application from occurring. The polish dried gritty and had no shine. And worst of all, by the end of day 2 I had a lot of chipping and they weren't small ones either! Such a gorgeous polish, but it's some work to get the desired results as they aren't going to come straight out of this bottle. I love the way the cornered bottles nest together and take up so little space and are so convenient for storage, but the brush is such a disappointment and frankly for $14, I expected a much better quality overall in this polish. I have 1.99 Wet n Wild polishes that outperform this $14 disaster. I'd buy this again as I love the color and the way it looks on once you get it finished, but I couldn't recommend this to a friend. Buy it only if you really love the color because that is all it has going for it. It would be great for a special occasion or date night, but don't expect it to last as long as your manis usually do. It's not going to happen. It was hard to say if I would buy it again. At $14, absolutely not, but if it were on sale then I certainly would as I am still sitting here looking at my mani even with chipped polish it is soo beautiful and I love this color. every little movement and my nails come alive with dancing lights. I have had many compliments on this mani.
*EDIT* You want a dupe for this for less than $2? Private Show by Pure Ice Seriously. I tested them on my own hands. Skip Butter London's cute package and buy the Pure Ice. Save yourself $ and hassle.
Age: 25-29 Skin: Normal, Fair, Cool Hair: Blond, Curly, Fine Eyes: Blue
This polish is gorgeous but it takes a bit of work for it to look flawless and awesome. I have heard some had luck using a bit of thinner in it right off the bat and also putting gelous base coat over it (before topcoat) to deal with the gritty texture or doing one coat of TBK over black. I like the polish so much and also really into BL a lot so I don't mind it taking some extra TLC...but it's also pretty chippy. More so than other BL polishes...I just think it's soooo pretty.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Dry, Medium, Warm Hair: Black, Wavy, Medium Eyes: Brown
I understand why some people won't like this polish, but I still love it! It does apply a little goopy, dries matte, and is gritty once dried, but Seche Vite fixes it all. I used 3 medium coats and finished off with 2 coats of Seche Vite top coat. It was a sparkly, smooth, and spectacular manicure. Love it!
Age: 30-35 Skin: Oily, Fair Hair: Blond, Straight, Fine Eyes: Blue
Bought this and saw that the glitter in this is the same as Sally Hansen's Rockstar Pink that I already owned. So I returned the Butter London since I can simply paint a coat of Rockstar Pink over a black polish and save $14. I am dying to have a Button London in my collection but they continue to disappoint me. :-(
Age: 19-24 Skin: Dry, Fair Hair: Blond Eyes: Green
I have tried two Butter London glitter polishes and I am so disappointed with both of them. This looks gorgeous in the bottle, but when put on the nails it is a very different story. It was opaque in 3 coats, but it was a very rough texture that not even a super thick top coat could fix. It actually dried to be a bit matte as well. And it chipped about two hours after wearing it! I've heard such great things about this brand but every polish I have tried has not lived up to any hype. I will be returning this polish for sure.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Dry, Fair Hair: Red Eyes: Hazel
I looooove this colour so much, black base with blue, hot pink and silver fine glitter running through it, this looks like tiny galaxies on my nails. The application was great, my bottle wasn't gloopy at all, I used base coat, three coats of The Black Knight and one layer of top coat. The polish still feels a tiny bit gritty after one layer of top coat so I usually put on a second coat the next day. This polish virtually chemically bonds with my nails so I get agggges of wear out of it, I usually take it off to switch colours, rather than because it has chipped. Like all the other Butter London polishes I have tried, this is amazing.
Age: 36-43 Skin: Combination, Fair, Warm Hair: Brown, Wavy, Medium Eyes: Green
I love ButterLondon polishes and this is no exception. It is a deep black with subtle flashes of multi-coloured glitter and it lasts roughly forever on my nails. I used BL base and top coat with it and it has been on for several days with almost no signs of wear. Not even tip wear. It was kind of thick and gloppy going on but I think cleaning the neck of the bottle and maybe a drop or two of thinner would easily fix that. I applied this right before cooking dinner, which I thought would ruin it, but it didn't. The following day there were no sheet marks and I was thrilled because I really didn't think I gave it enough time to really dry and harden. I proceeded to do chores all weekend, folding towels, cleaning out closets and drawers, opening boxes, dealing with the cat box, etc and nothing. Still looks great. Then it became an experiment to see how much abuse it would be able to take digging in my purse for keys, showers, nothing fazed it so far. It is growing out but still not chipping. It has a slight ding from a drawer being closed on it but it's not really visible to the naked eye, but I can feel it. I know the colour isn't super unusual, it can be frankened, and it's expensive but if you are looking for long lasting polish for a trip or something this will probably hold up the entire time. I want to take it off soon because I have untrieds I want to use and I'm afraid it will be more difficult than most glitter polish because it's bonded to my DNA or something. Highly recommended.
Age: 25-29 Skin: Sensitive, Fair, Warm Hair: Blond, Straight, Fine Eyes: Hazel
This polish is a beautiful color but it chips instantly! I applied this the first time with no base coat, 3 coats of black knight, and my essie top coat. within hours, huge chunks of this polish were peeling off my nails. it simply does not adhere to the nail at all! because this polish is so expensive, i refused to give up on it. i applied it again with a sticky base coat, 3 coats of black knight, and my usual topcoat again. I didn't have huge chunks sliding off my nails, but i did have chips the first day. for me, this polish is simply impossible. the fact that it is so expensive makes this lack of quality even worse. 2 stars because its a beautiful color, but minus 3 because it just doesnt wear well
Age: 36-43 Skin: Oily Hair: Blond Eyes: Blue
Love this color! It has a black base with fine fuchsia, turquoise, and silver micro glitters. I've gotten a lot of compliments on it. It looks so sparkly in the sun. It's my current favorite color. It applied pretty easily, but I don't like the brush. It seems cheap and it's very small. It was opaque in two coats. I love the butter bottles. They line up so nicely on my shelf. They are expensive and I rarely finish a polish, so I wouldn't rebuy. But the color is stunning. Love it.