|Would buy this product again.||63%|
Age: 19-24 Skin: Combination, Fair, Neutral Hair: Brunette, Straight, Medium Eyes: Brown
this is total CRAP. this expensive piece of little sh*t smudges crazy and irritates my eyes like there's no tomorrow. as soon as i apply it on my waterline my eyes tear up (this doesn't happen with other liners) and everything gets really messy. it's also not sharp enough to draw a fine line along my lash line so what i end up getting when i put it on my lash line is what looks like black eye shadow. this is so bad. feel like a total idiot to have given this a chance.
Age: 25-29 Skin: Normal, Fair, Cool Hair: Brunette, Wavy, Medium Eyes: Hazel
Tried this on in Sephora and loved it - creamy and glided on effortlessly and had very rich pigment. However, about and hour later my eyes started to feel very irritated. They were itchy, mucousy feeling and red. As soon as I got home I took out my contacts and still hours later my eyes are itching so bad I just took a Benadryl hoping it'll help. Going back tomorrow. Also, it may have been my bad reaction, but it was smudged all over place when I went to take it off so the staying power wasn't any better than my usual staple Makeup Forever Aqua Eyes.
Age: 30-35 Skin: Sensitive, Tan Hair: Black Eyes: Brown
The color is intense, I will give it that. However, this, like other creamy pencils I've used, smudges like crazy. Also, I do not like the packaging. The pencil is retractable and the sharpener is useless. Everytime I would try sharpening the tip, it would just break off. Not worth the money.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Normal, Fair, Warm Hair: Brunette Eyes: Brown
So I ONLY wear eyeliner on my top waterline. I'll tightline by wetting eyeshadow and placing it right into my lashes, and then I'll finish with an actual eyeliner on the upper waterline. I never put eyeliner on my bottom waterline because it closes off my eyes a little. What would always happen, however, is that within 30 minutes of putting eyeliner on my upper waterline, it would begin to transfer to the lower waterline. This would always happen especially when I was out with friends because I get super squinty when I laugh and before I knew it, my lower waterline was lined due to transferring lol.
So I went on a quest to find an eyeliner that would stay put without transferring. After trying so many different eyeliners, both drugstore and high end, I stumbled across the NARS eyeliner. I tried it on in the store and hours later when I looked in the mirror, I had the SLIGHTEST transfer. I'm talking about on a scale of 1-10 (10 being the worst) it was a level 1 transfer. This didn't bother me at all because I know it's impossible to find an eyeliner that will be 100% transfer proof, and this was hours after I put it on.
Still, I tried cheaper alternatives, because I didn't wanna spend so much on an eyeliner! Nothing even came close to it, so I finally gave it and purchased it.
I have NO regrets! This is the BEST eyeliner I have ever tried. I'll put it on and hours later it will be the same level of intense black without hardly any transferring at all, giving my eyes the definition that I want. I fell asleep with it on and when I woke up, it still didnt fade! Since it stayed so well put on my waterline I'm certain that even on your lids this will be smudge and fade proof. Definitely give it a try whenever you come across it in stores, I highly recommend this eyeliner.
Age: 25-29 Skin: Combination, Fair-Medium Hair: Black Eyes: Black
Definitely a very vivid black! Also goes on very smooth and creamy. I've tried many different pencil/crayon liners from drugstore to high-end and this is so far the best in terms of color and ease of application.
I am however, slightly disappointed with it's staying power. At the end of the work day (mine can run 12-16 hours long) I only see a faded marking of where I had used it on my waterline. Maybe I'm just being unfair though... does any eyeliner last that long? >.< For sure if you only need it to last up to 8 hours this would definitely be worth every penny. But for 10+ hours I am still looking!
Age: 19-24 Skin: Combination, Fair Hair: Blond Eyes: Blue
Love how pigmented this eyeliner is. It also lasts all day with out fading on bother upper lash line and water line. The twist up function is very easy and convienent to use. I felt bad paying as much as I did for this eyeliner but am glad I got it.
Age: 18 & Under Skin: Oily, Fair-Medium Hair: Brown Eyes: Brown
This is the best pencil liner I ever tried.
This eyeliner is a super creamy matte black and once you glide it on, its not going anywhere. Ive been look for an eyeliner that wont smudge on my waterline and this is it. At times i even have trouble getting it off but nothing a little makeup remover wont fix!
I also love how its retractable so I know i wont have to find a sharpener which is always a hassle. This also comes with a sharpener on the end so you can wing out your eyeliner too!
Will be purchasing this in different colors soon !
Age: 30-35 Skin: Dry, Fair-Medium Hair: Blond Eyes: Blue
I never thought I would spend $25 on eyeliner. I always bought the cheap drug store stuff and splurged on the rest of my MU. That all changed last fall when I got so tired of perpetually having black eyeliner smearing and dripping down my eyes making me look like I had just been asleep or crying or was going for a goth look.
In my experience with this liner it STAYS PUT. it didn't smudge, run etc... It is easy to apply. it is soft and does not drag at your delicate eyelid skin. And it is the blackest black eyer. It makes my grey/blue eyes really stand out. I love this eye liner. So much that I ran through a tube in less than 2 months. it was probably only 7 weeks. That is my #1 and only complaint about this product. It is WAY too little product for your money. GIve us a little more PLEASE! that tube is huge and I know the crayon inside doesn't go down the whole way.
Almost took a lippie off because of price. But decided not to because this is honestly the best jet black crayon eyeliner I have come across. I am not a fan of liquid eyeliners but this gives you the look of that without dealing with liquid.
Just bought my second tube of this. Plus another in Barrow street. Hope to collect them all.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Dry, Tan, Warm Hair: Brunette, Wavy, Coarse Eyes: Brown
Used my friends and I love it
doesnt require a sharperner
and is the Blackest Black
and i dont know what other people are talking about but it did NOT fade or anything
i'm picking one up too
I wore this out clubbing, and even after sweating and dancing It did not fade.
Age: 44-55 Skin: Dry, Medium Hair: Blond Eyes: Hazel
I purchased this in Sephora and told the SA I wanted an eyeliner for my waterline that didn't fade or smear. She suggested Nars. I love their eyeshadows and eyeshadow primer. THIS IS A LOSER! Put it on my waterline and within an hour it faded. Applied again same thing. So disappointed in this eyeliner I returned it.