|Would buy this product again.||76%|
Age: 19-24 Skin: Normal, Fair Hair: Black Eyes: Hazel
Amazing! I praise this stuff. The to go eyeliner for asian eyes, of course, you have to have steady hands. It takes practice but it's definitely worth it! Also it comes off easily with an oil based eye make up remover.
Age: 30-35 Skin: Normal, Medium, Warm Hair: Black Eyes: Black
Crap what a waste of my 8 bucks, prefer the ELF liquid eyeliner over this. Eyeliner is the most important thing for me. This products has more cons than pros IMO. Lets start with the packaging, looks good, nice and flashy gold packaging. Just don't get why the brush is this thick, the formula is goopy thick but can be worked with. This eyeliner formula is a like a tattoo, it stays put.. I mean really STAYS PUT! Removing this is a pain in my bu$$. I just use a rich cleanser to remove my makeup, don't have the time or patience for bedtime rituals. This eyeliner does not come off with a cleanser...boo on that! Try the ELF for a buck instead,
Age: 44-55 Skin: Normal, Fair-Medium, Cool Hair: Brunette, Wavy, Fine Eyes: Grey
I love the coppery shade, 04 Forever. Really sets off blue eyes. The fat brush and gooey formula made it difficult to get a fine line. I will not repurchase.
Age: 44-55 Skin: Combination Hair: Other Eyes: Brown
Only liner that does as it says. Stays on very oily, hooded lids, in extreme humidity and in the rain. People who don't like it, says its thick and that the brush is bad. I use a separate brush, a flat one, and dab it on the wand, then remove excess on tissue... I can then use a cotton swab to thin it out, on my lid, if it went on too thick, which, for any liner, will cause some flaking. If the formula gets thicker after several uses, just place closed tube in a cup of hot water (of course not completely immersed) to thin it out.
At the end of the day, no racoon eyes, creasing, disaappearing liner. Holy Grail!
Age: 36-43 Skin: Acne-prone, Fair Hair: Brown Eyes: Brown
Amazing! It lasts on my eyes. Doesn't flake or smudge. Comes off easily with makeup remover. Only the brush isn't as fine a point as I'd like. The gray emphasizes my eyes without looking unnatural. I LOVE this stuff. Oh and it's cheap! I'm buying the other colors.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Other, Fair-Medium Hair: Black, Straight, Fine Eyes: Black
Compared to MAC liquidlast eyeliner, this is far better. MAC's is indeed waterproof, but not completely invincible. It's weakness is flaking. After 24 hours or swimming, parts of it flakes off. Milani's, however, does not do that. It's also paraben free unlike MAC's. I'm so happy I found a better and cheaper alternative to my everyday staple liner. :)
Age: 25-29 Skin: Combination, Fair-Medium, Cool Hair: Brunette, Curly, Fine Eyes: Hazel
Pretty much an EXACT dupe of MAC liquid last eye liner. Which, in the past, was THE only liner that wouldn't melt all over my poor oily eyes/face.
But get real, who's going to pay MACs price when you can get THE EXACT PRODUCT from Milani for $6 at a drugstore (before coupons, member rewards, sales, etc). The price and staying power and color payoff CANNOT be beat.
The product can/does get thick pretty quickly and since I'm not blessed with the ability to master those stupid brushes with eyeliner, I've yet to get the finest line I want; however Milani has other options with the same staying power for that!
Overall, THIS product is what sold me on using the Milani line. I hope they never stop making products!!!!
Age: 19-24 Skin: Oily Hair: Brunette Eyes: Brown
**YOU MUST USE AN OIL TO REMOVE THIS.** I see so many reviewers scrubbing this off their eyes? Ridiculous! Use some olive oil first (or coconut, jojoba, etc) until it's gone, followed by your face wash. Fabulous eye-liner. Does not budge. I use a different brush, however.
Age: 30-35 Skin: Combination, Fair, Warm Hair: Red, Wavy, Fine Eyes: Green
I'm in the process of testing popular drugstore eyeliners, mostly those that are touted as being very black and waterproof/smudgeproof, so if that's what you're looking for, feel free to check my profile for further reviews/comparisons. As of writing this review, this is the 3rd review among the many many eyeliners I have purchased for this purpose.
The color I purchased is called "Everlast" (black)
*Insanely dark and rich black and has no weird bluish or greyish cast. No complaints here about this product's pigmentation. This product ranks #1 for pigmentation among the black eyeliners I've purchased for my experiment.
*This product **visually** blends seamlessly well into mascara-coated lashes and/or falsies (important to me cosmetically because I want my eyeliner to give the illusion of longer lashes and/or the illusion that my eyeshape is more lifted at the outer corners and more almond shaped than they naturally are. I don't wear eyeliner for the sake of looking like I use eyeliner).
*Is not harsh or stark-looking (see pro above)
*This products performs dramatically better than any eyeliner I've ever used, for lasting power (one application can last days!) and for not smudging, smearing, transferring, and creasing (doesn't occur with this product whatsoever).
*Because this product literally doesn't budge, I have the freedom to apply this product near and even around the innermost corners of my eyes without having to worry that I'll get those yucky black eye boogers. (ew, I know.)
*Doesn't peel or flake (a little bit of flaking will occur and progress, though, after 24 hours of wear)
*Very affordable (I think I got this for about 5 bucks) and you get a lot of product.
*The packaging and brush (which is attached to the lid) is pretty cumbersome because of how goopy this product is and because the packaging isn't designed to remove most of the excess product as you pull the wand out of the tube so there's a lot (a lot!) of goop all over the wand and the brush when you pull it out, so I have to use the mouth of the tube to wipe off all the excess product. Very very little product is needed for application, so I don't appreciate that I have to spend so much time trying to get all that excess product off the wand/brush and back in the tube (and creating a goopy mess around the mouth of the tube in the process.)
*Not the easiest product to apply. I have to really take my time to get a precise application, so if I'm in a hurry I won't reach for this product because of how careful I have to be in applying it (also for the previous con above). I would not recommend this eyeliner to anyone who has not had a helluva lot of practice applying liquid eyeliner, cuz with this product you don't have the freedom to correct mistakes. And this brings me to the last con:
*Very difficult to remove or near-impossible to correct mistakes. I can get it off with Lancome's makeup remover, but it still takes some elbow grease. Because it's so difficult to remove, I'll just wear it for 2 days and then remove it (much easier to remove by then).
Despite the cons, I really do love this product, and this is the second eye liner product I've used from Milani which I've been really impressed with. I would recommend their eye tech extreme liquid pen to beginners or those who don't want to spend a lot time fussing with application, and I recommend this eyeliner to those experienced in using liquid eyeliner who likes the pro's I listed and can put up with the cons.
Hope this was helpful. :-)
Age: 25-29 Skin: Very Dry, Tan Hair: Black, Straight, Medium Eyes: Brown
As someone who doesn't wear makeup everyday, this eyeliner (black, matte) has become my "go to" eyeliner when I want that defined eye look.
Although as some have mentioned as the product to get "goopy' some times, with even the little practice I've had, I'm able to achieve a simple liner look or dramatic, thick eyeliner look.
It definitely stays on all day no smudging is never an issue for me.
Age: 25-29 Skin: Oily, Medium, Warm Hair: Brunette, Straight Eyes: Brown
I'm on my third bottle. Ladies, if you're tired of smudging eyeliner, THIS IS FOR YOU!! Super long lasting; lasts and entire day and then some. If I don't get it all off with my cleanser in the evening, I just leave it there- now I have an outline for the next day LMAO. Super non irritating; no redness, bumps, or other unsightlies, even when I leave it on overnight (which I have been doing for months now...). Super fantastic; I tried two different high end brands from Sephora which didn't come close to this Milani Infinite. Both of those went back and after the second one I just went to Target to buy my HG eyeliner.
I've only tried the black (Everlast and I use Avon's makeup remover to get it off easily. The brush was super annoying, but I've perfected the technique by now. Keep a Q-tip handy for quick fixes, and if you're new to it, a piece of toilet paper or tissue to wipe off any that gets on your lashes. Bottom line, I LOVE THIS EYELINER!!
EDIT: 3/31/13 Fourth bottle. Target was out of my preferred color so I tried a different waterproof brand. BIG MISTAKE. I went to a different Target not two days later to return it and thankfully that one had my HG eye liner. So help me if this ever gets discontinued I will actually buy as many as I can get my greedy paws on!!
Age: 36-43 Skin: Combination, Fair, Neutral Hair: Red Eyes: Green
I purchased the shade 'Endless' as I've searching for a purple liner. I love the colour and the longevity of wear, but the formula and applicator are the liner's downfall. The formula is thick and kind of goopy combined with the long flimsy brush makes application cumbersome and difficult to control accuracy. Definitely a product I wouldn't repurchase nor recommend and my hunt for a decent purple liquid liner continues.
Age: 36-43 Skin: Combination, Tan Hair: Brown, Curly, Medium Eyes: Brown
I usually love Milani produts but not their liquid eye liner.
This stuff makes my eyes itch like crazy and it flakes really bad=(
I've tried 2 different bottles of this in black and both times same thing happens....I will stick with creme eyeliner cuz it works best for me.
Age: 44-55 Skin: Normal, Fair, Cool Hair: Brown, Wavy, Fine Eyes: Brown
I really liked the Milani eye liner pencil but am more used to a liquid product with a brush. I got this with great hopes, attracted to the "Infinite" part. Eyeliner disappears on me during the day---where does it go? So I need something that lasts. The first thing I noticed was that the product was rather thick and gloppy. To add to this problem, the brush is too big and not tapered. But I was willing to work with it. It DOES stay on, oh boy does it stay on. But I couldn't get a fine line. So I tried a smaller brush from another liquid eyeliner but the problem persisted. The product is just too thick. Bottom line (no pun!): Milani folks, please thin out this eyeliner, pair it with a delicate, tapered brush, and I'll be willing to try again.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Combination, Fair Hair: Blond Eyes: Blue
This is an EXACT dupe for the MAC liquid last liner in black. and I MEAN exactly the same because I have been using that MAC liner for months now.
If you want something that will no joke stay on ALL day, this is it. I remove it with an oil based eye makeup remover and it comes off easily. It has to be an oil based though.
Milani $ 5.99
MAC $ 22.00
plus you get triple the amount with Milani, for the exact same product with exact same results.
Age: 18 & Under Skin: Acne-prone, Fair-Medium Hair: Brunette Eyes: Brown
This eyeliner says "24 hour wear." ITS NOT KIDDING. Sure, this is great if you have oily lids but if you have dry lids during the winter like myself, this stuff is awful for it. The brush probably is one of the biggest reasons why I dislike this product, its AWFUL. This eyeliner literally took me hours to scrub off, and it irriatated the hell out of my eyes. I wouldnt buy again :(
Age: 19-24 Skin: Acne-prone, Fair-Medium Hair: Brown Eyes: Brown
I bought this product after reading rave reviews about it. Was excited when I got this the next day after I ordered it. As soon as I opened the bottle, I smelled something strange but I swatched it on my hand. The tip is definitely not the greatest one to apply a liquid eyeliner. And I noticed that mine was sticky! Right out of the bottle, it was sticky, thick and difficult to even apply it on my eyes. I don't know if this was the case with only mine...and after I managed to apply it on my eyes, it wouldn't come off at the end of the day! I literally had to scrub it off using jojoba oil...so this went straight to the trash!
Age: 19-24 Skin: Oily, Fair-Medium Hair: Black Eyes: Brown
This was my first liquid eyeliner. I have really hooded eyes, and unfortunately it gets progressively oilier throughout the day.
The pros of this eyeliner: 1) Amazing staying power. You do not need to worry about smudging at all. Once itís on, it takes a miracle to get it off. I wear it for 12 hours plus, and no smudging whatsoever. Because of my oily hooded lids, thereís usually some creasing at the end of the day, but zero smudging. 2) You canít beat the color intensity. I got the endless black, and boy was it black!
Cons: 1) Because it has such amazing staying power, you have but a few seconds to correct any mistakes. This was probably the biggest annoyance I have with this product. I often end up taking makeup off the entire eye just to correct a minor mis-stroke. Removing it at the end of the day also takes patience. I found out pretty quickly that using a makeup remover will barely budge the product, but using Vaseline works the best. Unfortunately, it still takes a lot of gentle rubbing to get it all off. 2) The product definitely gets thicker the longer you have it. I didnít start to notice it until after a few months (I donít wear it daily). Now thereís usually a glob of product on the brush every time I use it. At this point, Iím tossing it. I think the product is a tad on the thicker side regardless of how long you have it, as I feel like I have paint on my lids even when I first started using it. And I agree with the other reviewers, if it gets on your lashes Ė watch out for major clumps! 3) The brush is not the most user-friendly. I struggled with it for a while before finally getting the hang of it.
Overall, a decent product for the price, but Iím still trying out other brands to find my HG eyeliner. I think itís a good product for those who are really looking for serious staying power, but I canít use it on a daily basis. Itís too much of a torture making corrections and removing it. Iím currently using Wet Ďní Wild Megaliner, and the consistency is a definite improvement over Milani. It was such a relief to find the brush way more user-friendly than Milaniís as well.
Age: 18 & Under Skin: Combination, Fair, Neutral Hair: Brown, Wavy, Fine Eyes: Brown
This eyeliner is amazing! No other eyeliner stays on my oily eyelids as long as this one does. Ive repurchased this at least 5 times. It looks perfect even after a long day of work i would definitely recommend this eyeliner.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Oily Hair: Black Eyes: Brown
Bought this in black (endless). This baby stays put all day long. There is absolutely NO running, flaking, etc. My only gripe it that this may just be too good a product in the sense that it is waterproof and, after completely dried, is difficult to remove. I cannot remove this with my regular face cleansers (dove soap for sensitive skin or neutrogena pink grapefruit scrub). So, I have to resort to using my EVOO to remove which definitely takes time to soak in and scrub off.
The brush is easy to maneuver but can take some getting used to for the first few applications. I bought this during CVS BOGO 50% off sale. I must say, it is decently affordable for the quality of product.