|Would buy this product again.||81%|
Age: 18 & Under Skin: Combination, Fair-Medium Hair: Red Eyes: Green
MY FAVORITE LIQUID EYELINER! I am totally obsessed with doing winged (cats eye) eyeliner and do it almost every day and this eyeliner has proved to be my favorite for doing so. I tried the thinner Glam Eyes Rimmel eyeliner with the thinner applicator but I found it way too thin, this applicator is nice and thick and firm which makes application a breeze. It is a little thick, so tread lightly when forming your wings if you do them.
It stays fairly well for me except right at the very inside of my eyes, I suspect I accidentally rub that area often & its pretty greasy so it's understandable. I love the smoothness of the strokes I can get with this product. I'd definetly recommend it for anyone who likes liquid eyeliner and likes that dramatic, thick line like me.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Combination, Medium Hair: Black, Straight, Coarse Eyes: Brown
I can't believe how high this product has been rated... I'm on my third bottle now and I have really liked the first two bottles. Maybe Rimmel changed the formula or something but it's just terrible now. It just looks terrible when it's dried. I feel like I might as well be using a permanent texta to line my eyes.
Age: 25-29 Skin: Combination, Fair Hair: Red Eyes: Blue
I was a total eyeliner newbie when I bought this product. I went for the cheap price so I could try it out, see if a dark line would suit my look (my eyes and eyelids are very small so I wasn'r sure) and then not use it if I didn't feel it looked good enough, without having spent a lot of money. As with anything, doing a line takes a practise - and I needed a lot of it! This was a good product to practice on. At the beginning the brush takes in quite a bit of colour and requires a very delicate touch and needs a while to dry, but not so much you can't do a relatively thin line, if that's your thing.
Half-way through the bottle, I'd become a pro at applying eyeliner, and there wasn't anything wrong with this cheap, good product - the stay was optimal, and given the right time to dry properly on my lid, it didn't imprint on my upper lid (and my lids can be quite oily and thus eye shadow can end up creasing). I'll definitely be buying a second bottle when the time comes, and maybe even buy a different colour from the black I've been using, just to switch things up.
Age: 18 & Under Skin: Sensitive, Medium Hair: Black Eyes: Brown
I didn't like this at all! Not recommended for beginners. Intense black color, but too liquidy and runny. It is easy to smear when applying and is horrible to remove. The tip is too small and fine for me, I much prefer a marker/brush tip. Let my mom try it but she didn't like it either. We are going to see if we can return it.
Age: 36-43 Skin: Acne-prone, Medium Brown, Warm Hair: Black, Straight Eyes: Brown
I've written so many mascara reviews (as that is one cosmetic I use daily & cannot leave the house w/ out). Anyhow, point being, on the days I'm lazy with mascara & just want one coat I like to line my top eye-lids to fill in the spaces so to speak. I've got length but not a heck of a lot of volume so I like my lash line drawn in. I've brownish / dark beige skin so I spent a lot of time & money recently looking for a decent black liner. Most just weren't a rich pigment. I actually just started the line on the lid look again after neglecting it for years. So from Aug til Sept I bought a handful. Not one of them compared to how well Rimmel preforms on me. They didn't even have extra black left but even the reg black suits me fine. I like the matte finish. If I want a gloss finish I'll just reach for my Stilla liquid liner. It is an easy to use felt (not brush) tip too, which is perfect for me who's just starting this look up again after not since a teen. I've had it since the end of Sept, it's now mid Nov &, unlike my mascara (which I re-purchase every 6wks or less it seems), I do not feel I need to replace it yet. It does not have any scent nor does it feel dried or drying out as yet. I will certainly re-purchase as I love it the formula & the price.
Age: 18 & Under Skin: Normal, Fair Hair: Blond Eyes: Blue
I love this eyeliner! The applicator makes it easy to make a good, defined line. The color is a good black. It's my new favorite!
Age: 19-24 Skin: Acne-prone, Medium Hair: Brown Eyes: Blue
Really? I can't believe people like this product. The applicator is great but the eye liner itself is terrible. It is too liquid-y. It often gets in my eye from dripping and when it does dry it dries soooo blotchy and ugly. It's awful. I shouldn't have to reapply eye liner like I have to with this product.
Age: 25-29 Skin: Combination, Medium, Warm Hair: Blond, Straight, Medium Eyes: Black
I recently switched from Revlon ColorStay to this one and am pretty happy with it so far. For reference, I've been using liquid eyeliners for years and have pretty good control with them. This one I find very easy to control, and the brush contains just the right amount of product every time it comes out of the tube. The coverage is great as the colour is very black. The brush is very sharp so you can draw very thin lines with this one. Cat eyes can be done fairly easily as well. It washes off very easily as well.
The only negative thing about this product is that it always smudges! Maybe I have oilier eyelids than others because I wear moisturizer and don't use a setting powder, but this eyeliner smudges a lot on me. By the end of the day, the line is all over my eyelid. I'll try the setting powder and see if it improves.
Overall, it's great black eyeliner that's not too expensive. It costs 13 EUR (pricy) here, but I think it's way cheaper in North America and the UK.
Age: 19-24 Skin: Acne-prone, Fair-Medium Hair: Black Eyes: Brown
Love this!! My go-to eyeliner, tried and tested so many others but I always go back to this, I prefer the waterproof version of this (for obvious reasons!) I really like the small tip as it gives you full control of how much eyeliner goes onto the lid, along with the size and shape of the preferred liner style. Don't think I'll ever bother trying anything new as I've always been let down by other ones. Cheap, cheerful and lasts ages! I always buy 2 when their on offer, worth it!
Age: 30-35 Skin: Oily, Fair Hair: Brown Eyes: Hazel
Pretty good liquid liner in the drugstore price range. The colour is a very dark pigmented black, which is much better than many liquid liners, which often come out light black or dark grey. Fairly easy to control with the nib applicator, maybe not quite as easy as a pen liner but the colour payoff is better as is the lasting power. Pretty cheap for about a fiver in the UK. You could do much worse than trying this one.