Average Rating 3.6/5
Review by joolz2u
Like others here, this pencil smudges like crazy on me. For me there are no pros in this pencil. MAC Black Russian is WAY creamier than this one but does not smudge. I only use this on the upper lashes. What I can use on the waterline that won't smudge on me: MUFE aqua eyes, Dior waterproof liner & black eye shadow applied with liner brush.