This is my second bottle of remover that is finally HG material for me! It works so effectively removing every last bit of waterproof mascara. Most importantly, it does not irritate my eyes. I've always had trouble with eye makeup removers making my eyes watery and itchy. I used Pond's cold cream for years then suddenly developed an allergy to it. Tried this stuff after reading a review on MUA & decided this is great stuff for 5 bucks! Just as good as Lancome & Clinique which both caused my eyes problems.