Great eyeliner pencil for the price. I got mine for $2 when it was 40% off at Rite-Aid.
I like the thickness of the tip which is a bit thicker than most automatic pencils. It makes applying eyeliner faster.
Staying power is good. I don't have oily eyelids though. But it does stay all day with minimal fading. I have it in black, dark brown and mink. All three colors are great. Mink is a brown with shimmer. I use it over the black to make the black less harsh and add some shimmer.