I've used Neutrogena nighttime wipes for a while, but decided to try something else. I will probably stick to using the Ponds (or honestly I like Target's brand up&up just as well) because they are so much softer than Neutrogena wipes. They don't remove eye makeup quite as well as Neutrogena, but I never found a wipe that would remove mascara in one try anyways. They don't smell as good either, but who cares? It is going right in the trash!