This product sucks big time! My HG waterproof eye makeup remover is the Loreal Waterproof Eye & Lip makeup remover. But lately... I can't find it anywhere, only the gentle version which sucks too.
I cannot describe how much this crap sucks. First off, very very oily. Second, does not get my waterproof eye makeup off after leaving my eyes all watery and greasy. The most disgusting thing is after using it (I have to wash my face again after using this just to get the grease off), the next morning I put on fresh mascara and they smudge so easily, like all over my undereye after I blinked twice. I looked like a racoon! My mascara never smudges.