So far this seems like a good cleanser. I have oily, acne-prone skin but I have to wash my face very frequently due to exercise and I am also out in the cold a lot in the winter so my skin can get dry and flakey. I had been using just Clean & Clear's makeup dissolving cleanser every time I washed my face but I realized I needed something more gentle for the morning, when all I really need to remove is any dirt or impurities that might be on there.
I have tried a lot of cleansers, both for oily and sensitive skin, and lots have left me with dull, red, dry skin. This cleanser leaves my skin looking normal- like healthy, clean skin that is ready for makeup. If you have very oily skin I might suggest following up with a small amount of toner on the t zone to combat shine and blackheads.
I wouldn't trust this cleanser to remove makeup- atleast not heavy liquid foundations. But since I use a different cleanser at night, I don't mind. And to me removing eye makeup is a job for an eye makeup remover, not a face cleanser.