I gave 1 for price because it was a GWP & 2 for packaging for the same reason ! However, if this wasn't a GWP I would actually buy it for full retail price, I love it. It's the perfect color for me, a browned down rose, very natural. It's really a MLBB on my red pigmented lips, perhaps just a shade darker. This is foolproof to apply, melts perfectly into my lips.