Aurachi's review of Neutrogena Moisture Smooth Color Stick


57 reviews

70% would repurchase

Package Quality: 4.2

Price: $$

Package Quality: 4.2

Price: $$


There are 8 new shades for Spring 2016 - but with a different texture. Neutrogena says "Choose shades 10-80 for a sheer & shimmery finish. Choose NEW shades 90-180 for a bold & creamy finish." They do not say "reformulated," so we are keeping them all together.


Age: 19-24

Skin: Normal, Fair-Medium, Not Sure

Hair: Black, Straight, Fine

Eyes: Brown

This is probably my favorite "jumbo" pencil from the drugstore so far! I own all 3 drugstore jumbo pencil brands (revlon, covergirl, and neutrogena) and neutrogena's version is by far the most light weight on the lips. The ones I got all have micro shimmers which can be good or bad depending on your taste.(I give these a 4.5 btw >.<)
Link to swatches:
Full Size Image

I have 3 colors :
-Juicy peach: Looks like a sheered out version of Macs Shy Girl(It might be frosty on pigmented lips)
-Sweet watermelon: average baby pink(frosty!)
-Bright Berry: Similar to Revlon's lip butter in Berry Smooth mixed with Lollipop(not frosty but has micro shimmers)

-Sweet scent(kind of like berries/raspberries), but not overbearing
-No odd taste from what I can tell
-Softer lips after it wears off(from my experience)
-The shimmers in them aren't gritty
-Not a variety to choose from.(8 colors? I believe)
-Some are frosty and you can't really tell by looking at it.
-Shimmers on your lips when product wears off.

I would definitely repurchase! I'm planning to get fresh papaya next. :]
Edit: Juicy Peach is a tad pinker than Shy Girl and a little bit grainy. The other 2 colors I didn't feel anything

11 of 11 people found this helpful.

Read all 57 reviews of Moisture Smooth Color Stick

Popular Lipsticks

Lip Lingerie
Lip Lingerie
121 Reviews
Velvet Teddy
Velvet Teddy
286 Reviews
Kylie  Lip Kit
Kylie Lip Kit
60 Reviews
Lipsense Color
Lipsense Color
87 Reviews
Back to Top