EDIT: I've had this for a couple of months now. At first I liked it, but after spending more time with it, I must say I'm disappointed. There are a few good shadows in this palette, but overall, you really have to work with the shadows for the best color payoff. (It's best applied with your fingers then use a brush to blend.)
TOP ROW (MATTE):
1st: Similar to WnW's Brulee. Nice, smooth texture
2nd: Barely shows on my NC30-35 skin
3rd: Beautiful taupe color in the pan. Poor color payoff
4th: Most pigmented of the four matte colors
BOTTOM ROW (SHIMMER):
1st: Too shimmery and too much fallout for all over the lid or for highlighting under the brows
2nd: Only a shade darker than the 1st shimmer color. Again, too shimmery and too much fallout
3rd: An exact dupe for MAC's Amber Lights. Buttery texture, great pigmentation.
4th: Poor color payoff. Much darker in the pan than on your eye.
BLUSH & BRONZER: Great pigmentation, finely milled, smooth texture. My only issue is the bronzer is too light for my skin tone so it's barely noticeable.
HIGHLIGHTER: Too much shimmer for my taste.