I had heard great things about this product so I gave it a try. Luckily instead of buying it first, I went to Sephora and got two samples of their two darkest shades (11 & 12). I tried each on one half of my face and neither was quite right. 11 was just a little to light gave off an ashy cast and the other was just a little two dark. Finally I mixed the two and got my perfect shade. I really like the look and feel of this foundation since I HATE having the "I'm wearing foundation" feeling. It's very light and offers minimal coverage, which for me is a good thing. Unfortunately until UD comes out with an 11.5 shade I will not purchase this since I refuse to spend 80.00 on foundation. I gave the packaging quality a one because I've read a LOT of other reviews about this foundation leaking out of the top.