I feel that a lot of gel liners are hit or miss. Revlon's is a bit of a miss. I like the brush, generally. It's very similar to Maybelline's Lasting Drama liner and great for beginners. The product itself is just meh. I have this in black and do not find it to be all that pigmented (it looks more like a charcoal gray to me). If you're going for more of a natural look with, this may be more for you-however if you like something darker or more dramatic, you'll find yourself adding layers and layers & that's just annoying-especially if you're time pressed. The consistency of the product is nice and seems to last a while without smudging. I probably won't purchase this again unless they improve the formula.