Average Rating 3.5/5
Review by glamourdoll
I found that this eyeliner went on creamy and smooth & it lasted all day on my bottom eyelid. I bought this in Bold Brown, only because on some mornings I am too rushed to apply my Smashbox Jet Set. So I kept this in my purse for back-up use. I don't agree with the advertising claim that the product has the drama and impact of liquid liner. Come on, Maybelline, that has been tried before! Some of you will recall that BB gel liner was originally presented in pencil form. I agree with other reviewers that I had some trouble twisting up this pencil, so points off for that inconvenience. I also find that pencils like this one may seem cheap but really aren't. I find that cream/gel/liquid liners are a better value, at least for me. This product did not last me very long at all, so more points off for that too. I don't know that I will re-purchase, since I am planning to get the new Tarte eyeliner for those rushed mornings, and will review that product as well.