Average Rating 3.5/5
Review by MarsyMars
I have a serious love/hate relationship with this mascara. Part of me loves it - Perfect formula -- not too wet or too dry Perfect Applicator - Not plasticky or spindly (I'm looking at you cat eyes) Perfect look - fuller & longer lashes, with a natural look - My lashes but better. Part of me hates it - After wearing it for a few days, I experienced the same smudgy panda eyes that other reviewers have mentioned. But, I liked the good parts so much, that couldn't just give up on it. I used it for a few weeks, tinkering around to try to figure out a way to make it work. UD setting spray helps to keep panda eyes at bay. So does not opening your eyes too wide soon after application and waving the brush around for a few seconds before applying. None of these things completely ameliorated the problem and, with a heavy heart, I tossed the mascara. A few days later, while putting on some false eyelashes, I realized how much longer and fuller my real lashes had become over the past month. It was Get Up and Grow! Since then I have re-purchased it but in the waterproof version. It smudges less than the waterproof version, but there is still some smudging. I keep wearing it and continually trying to figure out a way to MacGuyver this stuff so that it doesn't smudge.