Maybelline for mascara is iffy for me, but this one worked. I like *some* of their Volum' Express line, but not all (liked Colossal Lash, HATE HATE HATE The Falsies, and haven't tried but don't hear good things about Plush either).

This one is a nice formula, doesn't clump or dry out horridly, the brush is nice and it adds volume. Looking at the pictures, I don't know HOW so many people got such a clumpy result!! Mine coats and separates each lash much better than some other brushes of similar style. I usually use more than one mascara at a time (usually a Cover girl Lash Blast) but this is perfect for the lower lashes and looks great on top as well to keep the lashes separate and full looking. It's a very good mascara. I would most definitely buy it again.

I love this mascara! I wear it almost everyday and it makes my lashes look fake. It lengthens, separates my lashes, adds volume and holds my curl. I have short asian lashes so this is awesome. It does flake so I always put a coat of waterproof mascara on my lashes after applying one by one. If you want longer and thicker looking lashes that looks fake and natural at the same time, GET THIS.

this mascara really makes my eyelashes and eyes stand out. my lashes look so voluminous, long, and big! no flaking. easy to remove (i have the washable kind). seriously the best mascara i've ever used - better than my previous fave lash blast. more natural looking and defined lashes than with lash blast. my HG! my lashes are naturally long, but thin and straight.

I LOVE THIS PRODUCT!!!!! It makes my lashes look amazing! People ask me all the time if I'm wearing fake eyelashes! Buy this product! I recommend the regular formula for daily use, but the water proof is great for summer! The water proof stayed on while tubing and a couple of face plants during wake boarding!

I tend to use multiple mascaras and multiple coats and this is great for layering. It really coats each lash one by one. I give it a three only because it was not what I was personally expecting but for its price and the brand it's great. It does what it's name implies.

I would probably give this a 3.5 instead of a four. My eyelashes are extremely sparse and pale, so I need a both volumizing and lengthening mascara that won't give me spidery looking lashes. This gave me great separation and length, but did little to boost the volume. There is virtually no clumping and I like the formula. I feel like the rubbery wands to better at separating lashes as opposed to giving great volume. The want is a smidge too big, but used carefully it doesn't prove a problem. The formula is wet so sometimes my eyelashes will touch my eyelid and leave behind the mascara. The smell is pretty strong and I notice if for about half an hour after application. There is no fading or flaking. I said I would buy it again, but not after trying a few more to see what else there is out there.

This mascara is great for separating eyelashes, does not clump, and gives great volume! Maybelline mascaras have always been a favourite of mine, and this mascara is no exception.

If Maybelline ever discontinues this I will cry! I have the blackest shade. It doesn't clump, separates and lifts my lashes like nobody's business. I love it! It makes my lashes look really long, too. I honestly think this gives more volume than my Benefit They're Real!. And for $5, I can afford to replace it every 3 months without cringing at the price. Definite keeper.

GREAT for SEPARATING LASHES!!! It really makes your lashes looks NATURAL and it provides so much VOLUME!!! I love this mascara, people always comment me about how many lashes I have and its all because of this product. It creates alot of volume, while still looking natural. There is no clumping at all!!! My only complaint is that it smudges a little after wearing it for a while, and I wish they had a darker color so it stands out more. But I do love this!!!!

Pros: - big, buildable volume and length
- holds a curl well
Cons: - flakes onto face a lot
- clumps up if you apply a lot
- smells bad, even after it is applied
- wand too big
- starts to look spidery