This is an amazing eyeliner. It is smooth and long lasting. I have it in the brown shade, which is a beautiful, matte brown. I have used YSL, Smashbox, and Buxom cream liners and this is definitely far better than all three in quality. And it costs only $3 dollars which is 1/10th of the price of the other ones. And I got it for $1.50 during a sale.
I bought this in a Black and Coffee. I was really happy with this product, it was highly pigmented and easy application. It just glide on my eyes. I actually liked the brush that it came with. It did smudge a bit, but it wasn't a big deal.
It's not necessarily bad...just, not all that great.
I have this in black, which really is a nice color. Very pigmented. However, that and the price is really where the pros end. I bought mine about a month and a half ago, and it's already pretty dry. I don't even use it every day, maybe once a week.
It's a bit difficult to apply for me, even with an angled eyeliner brush. Kind of streaky.
After about three hours, it's smudge city on my eyes, even with UDPP.
I probably would not repurchase simply because there are better eyeliners out there.
Medium-pigmented I would say, pretty dry for a "cream" product, staying power is like 3 hours? But for three dollars this really is good enough.
I bought the black one about six months ago, used it constantly for about a month, and then got a new gel liner and forgot about this one.
I went back to this one recently when my gel liner was gone and I wanted to do my cat-eye look. It had dried up, but I added a bit of water and it was still usable, although it was a bit difficult to get an even line with the brush they provided.
I have noticed that if I wear it all day, my eyes end up irritated and I have to take out my contacts earlier than usual...but overall, not bad for $1.
It smeared in the first few hours of wearings it so annoying :[ I actually liked the brush, but wished it was longer.
It works for me. Handy and useful. I come with the applicator which I love.
Pretty good liner, especially for the price.
Dried out quickly. The brush is a joke. Spend your $3 elsewhere.
I bought this in Metallic Olive, which is a dark brown/green. A great color is you have some gold in your iris. I think the trick with this eyeliner is a good eyeliner brush. I purchased Ulta's Professional Eye Liner Brush (not their regular eyeliner brush).
The consistency of the eyeliner is creamy but not gel-like. It was surprisingly easy to apply for a beginner like me. Stayed on just like I applied it through 8 hours of work and 2 hours of mowing grass. Didn't irritate my eyes upon application or for the duration I wore the eyeliner.
I still like the felt tip eyeliners better, but it was cheap as can be, so I would try other colors. Time will tell on how long it lasts before drying up.