i prefer this over angel. it is a soft, pretty pink i wear to work. it is much softer than my usual snob or gaga, etc. very pretty and creamy.

Beautiful subtle baby pink.. I have extremely fair skin and this is a great color on my skin tone. IMO it would look cheap on girls with much color to their skin but if you're fair its a beautiful pink and not overpowering. It just doesn't last very long on me but I love the cremesheen texture from MAC.

Absolutely love this lipstick, I am very pale (nw 5-10) and this looks absolutely beautiful, it's so understated. I have quite pigmented reddish lips and I use this lipstick without any liner and it gives a beautiful opaque wash of light pink.

just bought this today when I went in with some back 2 mac pots and im absolutely in LOVE. Its such a gorgeous color. To me its the perfect pink for everyday wear. I feel like it would compliment most skin tones. I did have to layer it on a bit but I have pretty pigmented lips. Overall I adore it and will continue to purchase this again and again.

I like this shade because its not too pink or bright. It is a great everyday color that I pair with a neural eye look. Love it!

I bought this because of the hype. I don't know why this has so many 'good' rates because I find it one of MAC's misses. This is a very drying lipstick IMO. I don't like the color on my lips either. Won't buy this again.

I felt like I really needed this in my collection but honestly, Creme Cup is not that friendly to NC45 skin. I can pair this with lip liner/gloss to make it flattering but it is a bit of a pain. The color itself is that super sexy wearable pale pink. It looks awesome on its own but does require some exfoliation prior to wearing. I would buy this again just because it looks so chic and fantastic if you just want a simple, creamy pink lip but I will keep an eye out for something a little more flattering on darker skin.

When I first tried this at a MAC counter, I thought it loked too white and washed me out so I did not purchase. I tried this on again on another day and ended up loving it! Not sure what happened...but it gave me the perfect pink nude! And it looks amazing with Revlon Super Lustrous gloss in Peach Petal! Love love love this l/s! NC 42 for reference.

Light mauve pink that leans more warm then Angel, it's also a bit brighter. Love the creamy sheer formula. It's pigmented without giving you that super opaque tacky look. Would repurchase.

I've always enjoyed MAC lipsticks, they're generally pretty moisturizing and have good pigmentation. I bought this a month ago and I keep it as my everyday/go-to lipstick in my purse. I'm a lover of neutral but not dead-looking lips and this is a nice creamy baby pink that gives my natural lips a nice polished colour. will buy again if I ever run out, MAC lipsticks are so inexpensive too, I paid $16CAD+tax for it.