While I like the colors this just doesn't stay on me for more then a couple of hours. I prefer Bobbi Brown gel liner it stays on all day.
I have several Smashbox creme liners and really like the application with these. They are the easiest eyeliner to put on that makes a perfect line every time. Nice range of colors as well. I have to take one point off because of smudging. These are not as budge proof as they say if you have a problem with eyeliners staying put. This product does work well for alot of people but does smear slightly on my oily lids.
This creme eyeliner is one of Pam Anderson's favorites - and with good reason. Smashing Caviar comes with its own small liner brush which I find works well enough for me to keep it around. The color of the product is a jet black, and it glides onto lids like velvet. I found the staying power to be better than with traditional liners/kohl liners, but those of you with oily lids or who need make-up to stay put extremely well may want to top it off with some powder/black eyeshadow, or apply a make-up sealant like BeneFit She Laq. Give Caviar a try at Sephora if you can, because reviews seem to be mixed, depending on your skin type.